Large Underwater Experiment Shows that “Turbidity Currents” are Not Just Currents, but Involve Movement of the Seafloor Itself

Release Date:

Turbidity currents have historically been described as fast-moving currents that sweep down submarine canyons, carrying sand and mud into the deep sea. But a new paper in Nature Communications shows that, rather than just consisting of sediment-laden seawater flowing over the seafloor, turbidity currents also involve large-scale movements of the seafloor itself.

This article is part of the October-November 2018 issue of the Sound Waves newsletter

Side-by-side photos of people on the deck of a ship, first lowering then hauling back in an instrument package.

Left: On October 6, 2016, scientists lowered an instrument package on a mooring into Monterey Canyon. The sediment trap (long funnel-shaped device) is designed to capture mud and sand carried in turbidity flows; the other sensors measure currents and suspended sediment. Right: On March 21, 2017, the sediment trap is gone and the mounting frame is mangled, having been exposed to several significant turbidity flows in one deployment. Photo credit: Katie Maier, USGS, MBARI.

Turbidity currents have historically been described as fast-moving currents that sweep down submarine canyons, carrying sand and mud into the deep sea. But a new paper in Nature Communications shows that, rather than just consisting of sediment-laden seawater flowing over the seafloor, turbidity currents also involve large-scale movements of the seafloor itself. This dramatic discovery, the result of an 18-month-long, multi-institutional study of Monterey Canyon, could help ocean engineers avoid damage to pipelines, communications cables, and other seafloor structures.

 “Turbidity currents have been hard to study because of their powerful nature,” said Kurt Rosenberger, a USGS oceanographer collaborating in the study. “Especially in the early days of research—the 1980s and ‘90s—they typically destroyed the instruments put in their paths to measure them.”

Geologists have known about turbidity currents since at least 1929, when a large earthquake triggered a violent current that traveled several hundred kilometers and damaged 12 trans-Atlantic communications cables. Turbidity currents are still a threat today, as people place more and more cables, pipelines, and other structures on the seafloor. Turbidity currents are also important to petroleum geologists because they leave behind layers of sediment that comprise some of the world’s largest oil reserves.

Despite almost a century of research, geologists have struggled to come up with a conceptual model that describes in detail how turbidity currents form and evolve. The Coordinated Canyon Experiment was designed, in part, to resolve this debate. During this 18-month-long study, researchers from the Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI), the USGS, the University of Hull, the National Oceanography Centre, the University of Southampton, the University of Durham, and the Ocean University of China combined their expertise and equipment to monitor a 50-kilometer-long (30-mile) stretch of Monterey Canyon in unprecedented detail.

A man crouches next to an instrument as he prepares and secures it on board a ship.

USGS oceanographer Kurt Rosenberger prepares a mooring for deployment from the research vessel Rachel Carson on October 6, 2015. The tan, cone-shaped instrument is a sediment trap. Near the far end of the trap is a CTD (with small red tag) for measuring seawater conductivity (related to salinity), temperature, and depth. The line held additional instruments, such as current meters, not shown here. Photo credit: Katie Maier, USGS, MBARI.

“The USGS helped set the stage for this experiment,” said Rosenberger, “by pioneering a design that positioned current-measuring devices, called ADCPs [acoustic Doppler current profilers] above the turbidity flows.” The ADCPs “look” downward to measure water speed and direction at many levels between the instrument and the seabed. In 2002–2003, the USGS measured four turbidity flows in Monterey Canyon, recording the first ever profiles of currents in a turbidity flow.

That early experiment measured currents just once an hour, owing to battery and memory limitations. Technological advances enabled the 2015–17 Coordinated Canyon Experiment to get a much fuller picture, with current meters recording data every 30 seconds. The recent experiment also covered more time and a larger area. Researchers placed over 50 different instruments at seven different locations in the canyon and made detailed measurements during 15 different turbidity flows. Almost all the flows began near the head of the canyon in water less than about 300 meters (1,000 feet) deep. Once initiated, the flows traveled at least several kilometers down the canyon. The three largest flows traveled over 50 kilometers (30 miles), sweeping past the deepest monitoring station in the canyon at a depth of 1,850 meters (6,000 feet).

This extensive research campaign showed that turbidity currents in Monterey Canyon involve both movements of water-saturated sediment and of sediment-laden water. As described in the recent Nature Communications paper, the most important part of the process is a dense layer of water-saturated sediment that moves rapidly over the bottom and remobilizes the upper few meters of the preexisting seafloor sediment.

Illustration of the seafloor showing depth and location and configuration of various instruments placed in a deep canyon.

Map showing general locations of seven monitoring stations (not to scale) that were deployed in Monterey Canyon during the multi-institution, 18-month-long Coordinated Canyon Experiment. The USGS deployed and maintained the three shallowest moorings, in water depths of about 300 meters (1,000 feet), 520 meters (1,700 feet), and 800 meters (2,600 feet). © 2018 MBARI; canyon image by David Fierstein.

Drawing showing how sediment moves along a slope underwater.

Rough diagram showing the new conceptual model for turbidity currents presented by the Coordinated Canyon Experiment team in a recent issue of Nature Communications. Note how the layer of liquified sediment extends down into the pre-existing seafloor sediment. © 2018 MBARI.

This is very different from previous conceptual models of turbidity currents, which focused on flows of turbid, sediment-laden water traveling above the seafloor. The authors of the recent paper did observe plumes of sediment-laden water during turbidity events, but they suggest that these are secondary features that form when the pulse of saturated sediment mixes into the overlying seawater.

“This whole experiment was an attempt to learn what was going on at the bottom of the canyon,” said Charlie Paull, MBARI marine geologist and first author of the recent paper. “For years, we have seen instruments on the bottom move in unexpected ways, and we suspected that the seafloor might be moving. Now we have real data that show when, where, and how this happens.”

Among the instruments used in the experiment were current meters mounted on seven moorings distributed along the canyon floor. Analyzing the data from these instruments and measuring the time it took for the flows to travel between the moorings, the researchers were surprised to find that the flows appeared to travel down the canyon at speeds greater than the actual measured water currents.

People stand on the stern of a ship guiding a piece of equipment that is attached to a crane.

Scientists deploy a mooring holding current meters and other instruments on October 6, 2015. Photo credit: Katie Maier, USGS, MBARI.

Although tilting and other movements of the current meters could explain some of these observations, the scientists eventually concluded that their instruments were not simply being moved by currents of turbid water flowing above the seafloor.

The researchers also placed beach-ball-sized sensors called benthic-event detectors (BEDs) in the seafloor. The BEDs were designed to be transported by turbidity flows while carrying instruments that recorded their depth, horizontal and vertical movement, and rotation. Other motion sensors were mounted on large, steel frames weighing up to 800 kilograms (1,760 pounds). These were designed to remain stationary while the flows passed around them.

However, both the BEDs and the heavy frames were carried far down the canyon during strong turbidity events. In fact, the heavy, awkwardly-shaped instrument frames often traveled just as fast as the relatively light, streamlined BEDs.

The researchers also noticed large sand waves, up to two meters (6.5 feet) tall, on the floor of the canyon. Repeated bottom surveys showed that these sand waves shifted dramatically during turbidity events, remolding the upper two to three meters of the seafloor. But the researchers still weren’t sure exactly how this remolding occurred.

The arm of a remotely operated vehicle holds a spherical instrument underwater near the bottom of the ocean.

Instruments such as this “benthic-event detector” (BED) helped scientists discover how sediment moves during turbidity events in Monterey Canyon. © 2016 MBARI.

Illustrations that show sand waves on the ocean floor at two different times, and how they changed and therefore migrated.

Scientists have known about sand waves on the floor of Monterey Canyon for a long time, but the Coordinated Canyon Experiment imaged them in unprecedented detail with autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs). Note how the shape and position of sand waves changed in these two images, acquired nearly 3 months apart. Modified from figure 5 in Nature Communications paper. 

Data from the BEDs provided an important clue. During many events, the BEDs did not just move down the canyon into deeper water, but traveled as fast or faster than the overlying water. They also moved up and down within the flow as much as three meters at regular intervals.

The researchers concluded that, rather than being “dragged” along the bottom by a strong current, their instruments were being “rafted” by a dense, bottom-hugging layer of water-saturated sediment. They hypothesized that the up-and-down motions of the BEDs occurred as the instruments traveled over individual sand waves. As Paull noted, “The BEDs provided an essential kernel of new data that allowed us to understand the movement of the seafloor for the first time.”

“Textbooks and modelling efforts have traditionally focused on dilute flows of sediment-laden water over the bottom,” Paull added. “But we now know that dilute flows are just part of the equation. It turns out that they are the tail end of the process, which really begins at the seafloor.”

Citation for the new article:

Paull, C.K., Talling, P.J., Maier, K.L., Parsons, D., Xu, J., Caress, D.W. Gwiazda, R., Lundsten, E.M., Anderson, K., Barry, J.P., Chaffey, M., O’Reilly, T., Rosenberger, K.J., Gales, J.A., Kieft, B., McGann, M., Simmons, S.M., McCann, M., Sumner, E.J., Clare, M.A., and Cartigny, M.J., 2018, Powerful turbidity currents driven by dense basal layers: Nature Communications, v.9 i.1, article number 4114, doi: 10.1038/s41467-018-06254-6.

Related Content

Filter Total Items: 1