Western Fisheries Science News, August 2015 | Issue 3.8

Release Date:

Where the Stream Meets the Road: Prioritizing Culvert Replacement for Fish Passage

Assessing a recently replaced culvert in Siuslaw National Forest.

Many culverts are barriers to fish passage (left) and need to be replaced to improve passage and connectivity. Joe Acosta, U.S. Forest Service engineer, assesses a recently replaced culvert in Siuslaw National Forest.  Photo credit: Rachel Reagan, USGS.

When people think about fish passage barriers, they often think of dams situated in large rivers. But, smaller streams across the world are also highly fragmented by in-stream structures such as culverts, many of which restrict or completely block fish passage. Retrofitting or replacing these structures is a high priority for restoring habitat connectivity for native fishes and other aquatic organisms in the Pacific Northwest. However, the task of restoring habitat connectivity for problematic stream-road crossings is daunting. Thousands of barriers are scattered throughout the region, and removal or changes to these barriers would require massive financial investments. Based on current assessments, land management agencies (i.e., the U.S. Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management) estimate that efforts to restore fish passage may ultimately cost over $375 million on federal lands in Oregon and Washington alone and will take decades to accomplish (GAO 2001). Because of these extreme time and cost estimates, there has been great need to ensure best allocation of resources. Assessing potential risks to road infrastructure from flooding, debris flows, and climate change is not always considered and may play an important role in the success of our investments over the long-term.

In a project supported by the North Pacific Landscape Conservation Cooperative (NPLCC1), USGS researchers Rachel Reagan (WFRC) and Jason Dunham (Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center) developed and implemented an approach for prioritizing culvert replacements that included considerations of fish access, culvert replacement costs, and potential climate change impacts on the risk of culvert failure.

The project involved collaboration with Jesse O’Hanley, University of Kent (UK), to include climate change and economic considerations to a fish passage optimization model. This project approach included consideration of expected costs throughout the life-cycle of culverts and an optimization model to select culvert replacements in the context of multiple objectives. The study was applied in Siuslaw National Forest, Oregon, a forest with hundreds of stream-road crossings where culverts are actively being replaced. Siuslaw National Forest is home to a variety of native fishes, including salmon, trout, sculpin, dace, and lamprey, all of which were considered in this study. The researchers worked together with biologists, hydrologists, and engineers to incorporate important elements and trade-offs that affect decisions for culvert replacements on Forest Service lands.                

Researchers found that the selection of culverts for replacement varied, depending on the replacement costs used, site-specific risk, upstream habitat goals, and species in question. The framework within this study will help determine which culverts to replace in order to improve connectivity for stream fishes, while considering a number of variables. The evaluation showed that climate change impacts did not change culvert replacement or size selections, but this could be different in areas predicted to have greater climate change impacts. This approach can be applied in other areas to aid on-the-ground decisions in terms of adapting to anticipated climate effects, allocating limited resources for restoration, and will lead to greater efficiencies. Findings from this research have already attracted interest and will be used in another NPLCC-funded project led by the Washington Fish & Wildlife Department that focuses on integrating climate change into design and permitting of water crossing structures.

Reagan, a biologist and Pathways Career Intern at WFRC, recently completed her graduate work at Oregon State University in the Fisheries and Wildlife Department. The prioritization project discussed here represents part of her graduate work and can be viewed at http://hdl.handle.net/1957/56111. To learn more about this project, contact Rachel Reagan at rreagan@usgs.gov or 509-538-2299, ext. 354.

 

1The NPLCC is a self-directed partnership between federal agencies, states, Tribes/First Nations, non-governmental organizations, universities, and other entities to collaboratively define science needs and jointly address broad-scale conservation issues, such as climate change.

Newsletter Author - Rachel Reagan

 

Events

USGS Hosts Department of State-Sponsored Field Trip for International Journalists:  On August 25, the WFRC hosted a visit from Department of State International Journalists from Southeast Asia. Jill Rolland, WFRC Director, and scientists John Beeman, Toby Kock, Rachel Reagan, and Jim Winton participated in scientific talks and a tour of the WFRC laboratories. The objective of this tour was intended to showcase U.S. leadership in developing sustainable fishing practices and addressing climate change’s impact on oceans. Talks by WFRC scientists covered work on fish passage, implications of climate change in the Columbia River, and fish health.  For more information, contact Jill Rolland at jrolland@usgs.gov or 206-526-6291.

USGS Scientists at National American Fisheries Society Meeting:  On August 16-20, USGS scientists from the WFRC lead sessions and presented research at the 145th annual meeting of the American Fisheries Society (AFS) in Portland, Oregon. Sessions and presentations included many topics, including fish passage, climate change impacts, fish health, habitat restoration, long-term river monitoring, dam removal evaluations, forage fish research, lamprey biology, and salmon life-cycle modeling. Many scientists at WFRC are active members of the AFS and participate in a variety of chapters and sections throughout the society.  For more information, contact Jill Rolland at jrolland@usgs.gov or 206-526-6291.

U.S Department of the Interior Scientists Lead Tour for Scientists from the People’s Democratic Republic of Laos:  On August 15, John Beeman (WFRC) and David Hand (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Columbia River Fisheries Program Office) hosted five scientists from Laos on a day-long tour of the area near Portland, Oregon prior to the annual meeting of the AFS. Beeman and Hand worked with the foreign scientists, representing the Lao Living Aquatic Resources Research Center and National University of Laos, earlier this year during a project of Interior’s International Technical Assistance Program. For more information contact: John Beeman at jbeeman@usgs.gov or 509-538-2299, ext. 257.

SISNAR Intern Earns MS: Laurie Porter successfully defended for her MS degree in resource management at Central Washington University in early August, 2014. Ms. Porter’s thesis was titled, “Behavioral response of Pacific lamprey (Entosphenus tridentatus) to predator odorants.” Data from her thesis will be used to develop new management techniques aimed at improving the upstream passage of adult fish. The MS thesis was the direct result of work Ms. Porter completed through a USGS, SISNAR (Student Interns in Support of Native American Relations) internship awarded to the WFRC in 2014. Major cooperators on the project were the Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation and NOAA. For more information contact:  Mike Hayes at mhayes@usgs.gov or 206-526-2537.

In the News

WFRC Researcher Discusses Changes in Fish Related to this Summers Warming Water Temperatures:  In a recent article for Inside the Outdoors with Jim Huckabay titled “Warm Water, Low Oxygen, Dead Salmon” USGS Fishery Biologist Toby Kock discusses how low flows and warm water temperatures are affecting salmon in the Columbia River during 2015.  Warmer temperatures are causing salmon to change their behavior and many are dying from columnaris, a bacterial infection that can affect fish.  Additionally higher water temperatures lead to decreased dissolved oxygen levels in the water which can also kill fish. For more information contact: Toby Kock at tkock@usgs.gov or 509-538-2299 ext. 215.

Publications

New Publication Explores Effect of Parasitic Copepods on Tagged Fish:  Fish movements and behavior are often studied using radio or acoustic tags. These studies generally assume the fish are otherwise healthy but this may not always be the case. In a recent observational study published in Animal Biotelemetry, USGS scientists found that a native parasitic copepod, which attaches to the gills and body of fish, may be having an effect on tagged fish. The parasite is common in western USA reservoirs and may affect survival of fish during proposed improvements in downstream passage mandated by a 2008 Biological Opinion. For more information contact:  John Beeman, jbeeman@usgs.gov or 509-538-2299, ext. 257.

Beeman, J.W., A.C. Hansen, and J.M. Sprando. 2015. Observational data on the effects of infection by the copepod Salmincola califor-niensis on the short- and long-term viability of juvenile Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) implanted with telemetry tags. Anim. Biotelem. 3:20. DOI: 10.1186/s40317-015-0056-5.

New Publication Describes Susceptibility of Native Fish to an Emerging Virus: Spring viremia of carp (SVC) is one of 8 fish virus diseases worldwide that requires immediate notification to the World Organization for Animal Health (Office International des Epizooties, OIE) when detected in new species or geographic area. Formerly thought to be restricted to Europe and Asia, common carp and koi are the most susceptible species and in Europe there has been long history of outbreaks and economic losses due to this viral disease. The first detection of the causative agent, spring viremia of carp virus (SVCV), in North America was from diseased koi in 2002 and resulted in extensive eradication efforts. To date, SVCV has been detected sporadically in carp from various regions of the US, but is still considered exotic. Investigation of the susceptibility of native species to introduced pathogens is essential to manage future outbreaks that may occur with emerging pathogens, such as SVCV. In a recent article of Aquaculture, USGS Western Fisheries Research Center scientists and colleagues describe the susceptibility testing of perch, cyprinid, and salmonid fish species to a US strain of SVCV to obtain an initial assessment of the potential risk that the virus might pose for resident fish populations in North America. For more information, contact Evi Emmenegger, eemmenegger@usgs.gov or 206- 526-2276.

Emmenegger, E.J., G.E. Sanders, C.M. Conway, F.P. Binkowski, J.R. Winton, and G. Kurath. 2016. Experimental infection of six North American fish species with the North Carolina strain of spring Viremia of Carp Virus. Aquaculture 450: 273-282. DOI: 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2015.07.007.

Assessing Juvenile Salmon Rearing Habitat and Associated Predation Risk in the Lower Snake River Reservoir:  USGS, Western Fisheries researchers and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers have co-authored a new publication in River Research and Applications entitled “Assessing Juvenile Salmon Rearing Habitat and Associated Predation Risk in the Lower Snake River Reservoir.”  The researchers assessed the amount and spatial arrangement of subyearling rearing habitat in Lower Granite Reservoir on the Snake River to guide future habitat improvement efforts. For more information, contact Ken Tiffan at ktiffan@usgs.gov or 509-538-2299 x279.

Tiffan, K.F., J.R. Hatten, and D.A. Trachtenbarg. 2015. Assessing juvenile salmon rearing habi-tat and associated predation risk in a lower Snake River reservoir. River Res. Appl. 32(5): 1030-1038. DOI: 10.1002/rra.2934

Related Content

Filter Total Items: 1