Reply to the discussion by Pilfold “Polar bear mass change confirms hyperphagia follows ringed seal whelping”

The spring is a critical period when polar bears (Ursus maritimus Phipps, 1774) are thought to have peak access to seals and acquire the majority of their annual energy requirements during a period of hyperphagia. Pagano et al. (Pagano A.M., Atkinson S.N., and Archer L.C. 2025. Arctic Science.11:1-14. doi:10.1139/as-2024-0051) examined the intra-seasonal changes in body mass of 31 polar bears on the spring sea ice and found polar bears exhibited a feast or famine lifestyle. A lack of a relationship between changes in body mass and recapture date suggested that many bears had not entered their primary period of hyperphagia. Pilfold extended our discussion to conclude that our data show polar bear hyperphagia begins after the period of ringed seal (Pusa hispida Schreber, 1775) whelping, and discusses this in relation to previous work on the timing of polar bear seal kills. Here, we reassess whether our data provide information on the timing of polar bear hyperphagia. We find no relationships in our data to conclude when polar bear hyperphagia begins. Instead, our data highlight the conflicting pressures individuals face between the spring breeding season, when time spent foraging is often reduced to engage in mating behavior, and the spring hyperphagia period, when the bulk of annual energy requirements are met.