Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

March 24, 2026

Why are geologists so picky about rock samples? If you've ever watched one at work, you might notice that some rocks pass inspection, but others get discarded. Obviously a rock can't spoil like a piece a fruit, so what's going on?

The California Volcano Monitor is a weekly column written by scientists and collaborators of the California Volcano Observatory. This week's contribution is from Jessica Ball, volcanologist with the U.S. Geological Survey.

 

Media
A geologist wearing a blue button-down shirt, khaki pants, and an orange ball cap uses a rock hammer to break smaller chunks off the large, weathered, brownish boulders that surround him. The interior of the chunks is revealed to be a pale, speckled gray.
Geologists often break off the weathered surfaces of rocks in the field to get at the fresh, clean cores. This makes it easier to see the original mineralogy of the rock in question without oxidation, alteration, or other environmental impacts. USGS photo by D. Blatter.
Media
A geologist in a blue shirt and khakis supports a basketball-sized chunk of lava on his knee. A bright white "rind" makes up about half of the chunk, surrounding a core of dark gray lava speckled with white crystals. A marker rests on the chunk for a sense of scale, and similar white chunks of lava make up the background of the photo.
Geologists often break off the weathered surfaces of rocks in the field to get at the fresh, clean cores. This makes it easier to see the original mineralogy of the rock in question without oxidation, alteration, or other environmental impacts. USGS photo by D. Blatter

In the case of these lavas from the Clear Lake Volcanic Field in California, the rock that was erupted is not the same as the rock that we can see today. The first photo shows weathered boulders of lava revealing lighter, cleaner-looking interiors when broken. In the second photo, differences in color from the center to the edges of a chunk of lava reveal the effects of weathering and mineral alteration. Typically, these changes involve water, gas, heat, pressure, or some combination of the three. In the case of the lava in the second photo, hydrothermal alteration (hot, acidic water cooking the rock) removed iron and magnesium and left behind mostly silica. That's why the outside rind is lighter and looks powdery, while the core of the rock looks darker.

Because of these changes, altered rocks don't have the same characteristics they started with. If we want to learn about their age, what kind of eruption formed them, or where it came from below the Earth's surface, we can't use those parts of the rocks. We have to remove the "rotten" bits and take only the "fresh" rock inside, a bit like you might cut away the bruised parts of an apple. As with fruit, fresh is best!

Was this page helpful?