A post-restoration evaluation of fish spawning on Coreyon Reef in Saginaw Bay, Lake Huron

Habitat diversity is important to fisheries for promoting resiliency to interannual environmental variation. Historical land use change resulting in increased sedimentation has impaired fish rock reef habitats in Saginaw Bay, Lake Huron. Pursuant to the recovery of Saginaw Bay’s walleye population, and to benefit other species, came the decision to restore the offshore habitat Coreyon Reef, a 0.8 ha rock reef complex. Following a pre-restoration assessment in 2014–2016 and construction in 2019, we conducted a comprehensive assessment from fall 2020 to spring 2022 to document the restored habitat’s viability for fish spawning. This assessment featured two objectives: (1) to evaluate reproductive usage by lake whitefish and walleye, and (2) to evaluate their corresponding egg incubation environment. We sampled directly on Coreyon Reef and at nearby unrestored control sites for comparison, with gears standardized to the pre-restoration assessment. We confirmed spawning of lake whitefish and walleye on the restored reef less than 2 years post-construction. Relative to the pre-restoration assessment, peak egg deposition increased substantially for walleye and marginally for lake whitefish. However, concurrent reproductive utilization at nearby unrestored sites was consistent or even greater than directly on the restored site. Dissolved oxygen concentration was sufficient for embryo development, but invasive round goby were abundant and consumed eggs. The fish assemblage at our sampling sites was consistent before and after restoration. We predict eggs deposited on the restored site have improved survival relative to unrestored sites, as the new reef structure may protect incubating embryos from predation and sedimentation.