Variability of discharge, nutrients, and Escherichia coli from tile drains in a small agricultural stream, a synoptic study in the School Branch watershed, Hendricks County, Indiana

The U.S. Geological Survey, in cooperation with the Indiana Department of Environmental Management, sampled a 1-mile stream reach of School Branch in Hendricks County, Indiana. Sampling consisted of 24 tile drain sites and surface-water sites both upstream and downstream from the tile drains. This study intended to (1) assess the variability of discharge, nutrients, and Escherichia coli (E. coli) among tiles within a stream reach in variable conditions; (2) define how the tiles affect the stream hydrology and water quality; and (3) determine potential management implications. Samples were collected on three dates—round 1 on June 12, 2018, after fertilizer was applied; round 2 on September 11, 2018, in fall harvest conditions; and round 3 on April 16, 2019, before fertilizer was applied—to encompass differing precipitation events, multiple seasons, and field conditions. Sites were sampled for water-quality parameters, dissolved and total nutrients (ammonia, nitrate plus nitrite, total nitrogen, orthophosphate, and total phosphorus), E. coli, and instantaneous discharge. Instantaneous nutrient loads were calculated from tiles and at the upstream and downstream surface-water sites.

Nutrient concentrations and instantaneous loads varied depending on the tile and the sampling date. Tiles contributed between 26.5 and 66.0 percent of increased discharge between the surface-water sites. Tiles contributed between 34.7 and 87.4 percent and between 19.7 and 65.9 percent of the increased total nitrogen and phosphorus loads, respectively, for the downstream site relative to the upstream site. Most of the total nitrogen and total phosphorus from the tiles was in the dissolved forms (nitrate plus nitrite and orthophosphate). Surface-water samples had a nitrate plus nitrite to total nitrogen ratio of 71 to 93 percent, with an average of 82 percent; tile samples ranged from 44 to nearly 100 percent, with an average of 91 percent dissolved nitrogen. Surface-water samples had an orthophosphate to total phosphorus ratio of 30 to 65 percent, with an average of 53 percent; tile samples ranged from 32 to nearly 100 percent, with an average of 85 percent dissolved phosphorus.

E. coli was detected in all but 5.79 percent of tile and surface-water samples. The E. coli results indicated the possibility of human or animal fecal contamination by way of septic systems leaking or directly linked to the tiles draining into the study area. Consequently, five microbial source tracking samples were collected from the upstream and downstream surface-water sites between August 3, 2021, and May 18, 2022. Human, canine, ruminant, and avian sources of fecal contamination were evaluated. The microbial source tracking samples indicated that human-specific sources are likely consistently contributing to elevated fecal contamination.

Differences in discharge, nutrient concentrations, nutrient loads, and E. coli concentrations show that many factors affect how tiles alter the hydrology and water quality of receiving waters. The timing and severity of precipitation events, season, and the antecedent conditions of the field or watershed before sampling can affect the results. Tiles with the largest discharge rate had the most potential effect on the water quality and quantity of the stream. Targeting high-flowing tiles may affect efforts to improve overall water quality.