Whole Ecosystem Restoration Through Liming of Honnedaga Lake Tributary Watersheds

Acid rain levels in the Adirondack region have substantially declined and recovery from acid rain is underway. Recovery is being limited by the depletion of soil calcium that occurred over past decades. Not only is calcium needed for neutralizing acidity, it is an essential nutrient for terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. However, recovery of soil calcium has not yet been observed.

Whole-ecosystem restoration through watershed liming, possibly combined with in-stream liming, may provide a practical option for stimulating recovery of certain acid-sensitive, high-value natural resources. Information from past liming efforts, however, is insufficient for determining the degree of success that could be achieved with liming under contemporary levels of acid rain and soil-calcium depletion. To evaluate this treatment approach, lime is being applied aerially to an entire watershed and also directly to the channels of two streams outside the limed watershed.

The study is being conducted in the Honnedaga Lake watershed in the southwestern Adirondack region, where acid rain effects on soils and surface waters are among the most severe in the eastern U.S. The effects are being monitored through measurements of soil and soil-water chemistry, tree growth and regeneration, soil fauna, stream chemistry, aquatic invertebrates and brook trout.

In an accompanying study, the effects of the lime application on mercury bioaccumulation are also studied. [See: The Effects of Watershed and Stream Liming on Mercury Dynamics at Honnedaga Lake] The Adirondack region is considered a “hot spot” where high levels of mercury bioaccumulation have been measured in fish and birds. Mercury released into the environment through the burning of coal is transported in association with dissolved organic carbon, which is expected to increase from the liming. However, liming will also ameliorate acidic conditions that favor the mobilization and transport of mercury.  Therefore, effects of liming on the mobilization of mercury are uncertain.

Key Results

1.                 
The eastern
red-backed salamander (Plethodon cinereus) is a highly abundant top predator of
the northern hardwood forest floor. Early research found that P. cinereus was
sensitive to acidic soils, avoiding substrates with pH < 3.8 and
experiencing decreased growth rates in acidic habitats.  Based on that research, liming of acidified
watersheds such as those surrounding Honnedaga Lake was hypothesized to increase
growth and abundance of this salamander species.  However, analysis of salamander populations
in untreated watersheds of the study area revealed that populations of
red-backed salamanders were most limited by competition with dusky salamanders
(Desmognathus spp.).  Therefore, the
effects of liming on red-backed salamanders is unclear because it will depend
on how the change in soil chemistry will affect the interspecific dynamics of salamander
populations in these watersheds.

2.                 
Earthworms are
considered intolerant of acidic soils and are not native to the Adirondack
region.  Therefore it was hypothesized
that liming the acidified Honnedaga soils would create habitat suitable for
earthworms, which are easily spread by fisherman.  Once established, earthworms can greatly
accelerate decomposition of organic matter, alter soil nutrient cycling and
cause organic matter to be transferred from the forest floor deep into the
mineral soil, thereby altering root development and competition between tree
species.  A microcosm experiment using
native Honnedaga soils, both limed and unlimed, showed that a substantial
reduction in soil acidity did in fact result in high survival rates of
earthworms (Lumbricus terrestris), whereas 100% mortality occurred in unlimed
soils.

3.                 
The
only management option other than emissions reductions for combating the
effects of acidic deposition has been the application of lime to neutralize
acidity after it has been deposited on the landscape.  However, continued declines in acidic
deposition have led to partial recovery of surface water chemistry, and the
start of soil recovery. Liming is therefore no longer needed to prevent further
damage.  As more is learned about
recovering ecosystems, it has become clear that recovery rates vary with
watershed characteristics and among ecosystem components.  Lakes appear to show the strongest recovery,
but recovery in streams is sluggish and recovery of soils appears to be in the
early stages. Where in the system the lime is applied is therefore critical in how
the treatment effects various ecosystem components.  Application of lime to a watershed provides
the advantage of increasing Ca availability in the terrestrial system and
reducing or preventing mobilization of toxic Al, an outcome that is beneficial
to both terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. 
However, the goal should not be complete neutralization of soil acidity,
which is naturally produced.  Liming of
naturally acidic areas such as wetlands should also be avoided to prevent
damage to indigenous species that rely on an acidic environment.

4.                 
In-stream and aerial (whole-watershed) liming of
three acidified tributary watersheds of a high-elevation Adirondack lake in New
York State resulted
in marked improvements in water chemistry in all three limed streams.  However, results generally suggested that
neither liming technique succeeded in improving the condition of aquatic macroinvertebrate
communities. The watershed application caused a brief and unsustained decrease
in the density of macroinvertebrates and increase in the proportion of
sensitive taxa. The in-stream applications appeared to reduce the abundance of
macroinvertebrates, particularly in one stream where undissolved lime covered
the natural substrate. The close proximity of our study sites to the in-stream
application points (50 and 1200 m) may partly explain these negative effects.
Our results are consistent with prior studies of in-stream liming which
indicate that this technique often fails to restore macroinvertebrate
communities to a pre-acidification condition, especially at distances < 1.5
km downstream of the lime application point. The inability of either liming
technique to improve the condition of macroinvertebrate communities may be
partly explained by the persistence of acidic episodes in all three streams.
This suggests that in order to be effective, liming programs should be aimed at
avoiding even temporary episodes of unsuitable water chemistry rather than just
meeting minimal criteria the majority of the time.

5.                 
To
investigate liming as a method to accelerate recovery of brook trout, the
channels of two acidified streams were limed annually from 2012 to 2015; and an
entire watershed of a third acidified tributary was limed by helicopter in
2013.  Stream flow, water chemistry, and
density of young-of-year (YOY) brook trout were measured in limed streams, an
untreated acidified stream, and a buffered reference stream.  Lime additions increased pH and acid
neutralizing capacity and decreased inorganic monomeric aluminum concentrations
to less than 2.0 µmol/L, the minimum concentration at which in situ brook trout
mortality has been documented.  However,
of the two channel-limed streams, only stream T8 showed a significant response
(P < 0.01) in YOY density; increasing from a mean of 0.4 fish/m2 before
liming to 2.7 fish/m2 after liming.  No
YOY brook trout response was observed in the stream within the limed watershed.
Groundwater inputs to streams were identified by relative differences in
temperature and concentrations of silica and sodium. YOY brook trout densities
increased only in the channel-limed stream (T8) with suitable groundwater
inputs for fall spawning and a summer nursery. 
Results suggest that targeted liming of acidified streams with the
necessary groundwater habitat could be beneficial in accelerating recovery of
brook trout populations.

References

·       Beier, C. M., A. M. Woods, K. P. Hotopp, J. P. Gibbs, M. J. Mitchel, M. Dovciak, D. J. Leopold, G. B. Lawrence, and B. P. Page. 2012. Changes in faunal and vegetation communities along a soil calcium gradient in northern hardwood forests. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 42:1141-1152.  http://pubs.er.usgs.gov/publication/70038986

·       Lawrence, G. B., K. M. Roy, B. P. Baldigo, H. A. Simonin, S. B. Capone, J. S. Sutherland, S. A. Nierswicki-Bauer, and C. W. Boylen. 2008. Chronic and episodic acidification of Adirondack Streams from Acid Rain in 2003-2005. Journal of Environmental Quality 37:2264-2274.  https://dl.sciencesocieties.org/publications/jeq/articles/37/6/2264

·       Lawrence, G. B., W. C. Shortle, M. B. David, K. T. Smith, R. A. F. Warby, and A. G. Lapenis. 2012. Early indications of soil recovery from acidic deposition in U.S. red spruce forests. Soil Science Society of America Journal 76:1407-1417.  http://www.nrs.fs.fed.us/pubs/jrnl/2012/nrs_2012_lawrence_001.pdf   

·       Lawrence, G. B., H. A. Simonin, B. P. Baldigo, K. M. Roy, and S. B. Capone. 2011. Changes in the chemistry of acidifed Adirondack streams from the early 1980s to 2008. Environmental Pollution 159:2750-2758.  http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0269749111002831

·       Long, R. P., S. B. Horsley, R. A. Hallet, and S. W. Bailey. 2009. Sugar maple growth in relation to nutrition and stress in the Northeastern United States. Ecological Applications 19:1454-1466.  http://www.jstor.org/stable/40346260 

 Project
Location by County

Herkimer County, NY