Differences in inferred rangeland vegetation condition among satellite- and field-based estimates, before or after wildfire
November 6, 2026
- Pre- and post-wildfire management is increasingly guided by fractional vegetation cover (FVC) products, that is, maps parameterized with satellite imagery, that are used to determine where, when and how vegetation can be managed to moderate ecosystem impacts of wildfire. Several recent FVC products have transformed the science and management of wildland fuels and fire by estimating the type and abundance of vegetation across continuous regional areas. Additional guidance can help inform how well FVC products are parameterized for such broad areas and how they can be applied to the smaller scales at which vegetation is most directly managed for wildfire.
- We asked how inference for pre- and post-wildfire management would differ between the most common FVC products and benchmark field data in four scenarios of sagebrush-steppe management in the Great Basin, USA. Case studies included herbicide treatments in California and Nevada, a livestock exclusion in Colorado, post-fire seeding in Utah and wildfire risk assessment in Idaho. FVC products included the U.S. Department of Agriculture Rangeland Analysis Platform (RAP) and the USGS Rangeland Condition Monitoring and Assessment Program (RCMAP), both 30 m pixel resolution.
- Agreement in vegetation change or variability between FVC products and field data, specifically the variability in vegetation cover attributable to treatments or wildfire risks, was modest and evident mainly in terms of directionality and not magnitude. We found weak support for the concept of greater agreement among data sources across larger sites, when differences in vegetation across time or space were larger, and when the abundance of the vegetation of interest was moderate.
- Practical implication. Conclusions about management conditions would differ meaningfully if based on the benchmark field data compared to FVC products and also between FVC products. When using FVC products for management, the management question can be matched to the limitations of the data source or multiple lines of evidence can be integrated together.
Citation Information
| Publication Year | 2026 |
|---|---|
| Title | Differences in inferred rangeland vegetation condition among satellite- and field-based estimates, before or after wildfire |
| DOI | 10.1002/2688-8319.70346 |
| Authors | Cara Applestein, Matthew J. Germino, Michael Miley, Chad Raymond Kluender |
| Publication Type | Article |
| Publication Subtype | Journal Article |
| Series Title | Ecological Solutions and Evidence |
| Index ID | 70283721 |
| Record Source | USGS Publications Warehouse |
| USGS Organization | Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center |
Related
Vegetation cover and standard fire behavior fuel model information collected for two national parks in southern Idaho during the summer of 2023 Vegetation cover and standard fire behavior fuel model information collected for two national parks in southern Idaho during the summer of 2023
Data set includes field observed cover of several vegetation functional groups, e.g. annual herbaceous, perennial herbaceous, exotic annual grasses, perennial bunch grasses, shrubs, sagebrush shrubs, non-sagebrush shrubs, bare mineral soil, rocks, and litter. Additionally, if tree canopy was present within field plots, tree canopy cover was estimated, forest type recorded, and the number...
Functional group cover and treatment data for 13 sites in the Great Basin with reburn history Functional group cover and treatment data for 13 sites in the Great Basin with reburn history
Land management treatments in sagebrush steppe are an important opportunity to break the annual-grass fire cycle, provided they offer long-lasting resistance to annual-grass invasion and do not burn. However, for BLM areas seeded as part of the Emergency Stabilization and Rehabilitation (ESR) program, one of the largest programs for land management treatments, about 1/4 have at least...
Rangeland Condition Monitoring Assessment and Projection (RCMAP) Fractional Component Time-Series Across Western North America from 1985-2024 Rangeland Condition Monitoring Assessment and Projection (RCMAP) Fractional Component Time-Series Across Western North America from 1985-2024
The RCMAP (Rangeland Condition Monitoring Assessment and Projection) dataset quantifies the percent cover of rangeland components across western North America using Landsat imagery from 1985-2024. The RCMAP product suite consists of ten fractional components: annual herbaceous, bare ground, herbaceous, litter, non-sagebrush shrub, perennial herbaceous, sagebrush, shrub, tree, and shrub...
Vegetation and soil cover data for long-term monitoring plots within Browns Park National Wildlife Refuge, Colorado, USA Vegetation and soil cover data for long-term monitoring plots within Browns Park National Wildlife Refuge, Colorado, USA
Sixty-eight monitoring plots within the Browns Park National Wildlife refuge in Northwest Colorado were surveyed in the Summer of 2007 and 2021 for vegetation-community changes after grazing cessation in 1986. Surveys consisted of line-point intercept measurements at 0.5m intervals along three 15-m transects arranged in a spoke around plot center at each plot location.
Related
Vegetation cover and standard fire behavior fuel model information collected for two national parks in southern Idaho during the summer of 2023 Vegetation cover and standard fire behavior fuel model information collected for two national parks in southern Idaho during the summer of 2023
Data set includes field observed cover of several vegetation functional groups, e.g. annual herbaceous, perennial herbaceous, exotic annual grasses, perennial bunch grasses, shrubs, sagebrush shrubs, non-sagebrush shrubs, bare mineral soil, rocks, and litter. Additionally, if tree canopy was present within field plots, tree canopy cover was estimated, forest type recorded, and the number...
Functional group cover and treatment data for 13 sites in the Great Basin with reburn history Functional group cover and treatment data for 13 sites in the Great Basin with reburn history
Land management treatments in sagebrush steppe are an important opportunity to break the annual-grass fire cycle, provided they offer long-lasting resistance to annual-grass invasion and do not burn. However, for BLM areas seeded as part of the Emergency Stabilization and Rehabilitation (ESR) program, one of the largest programs for land management treatments, about 1/4 have at least...
Rangeland Condition Monitoring Assessment and Projection (RCMAP) Fractional Component Time-Series Across Western North America from 1985-2024 Rangeland Condition Monitoring Assessment and Projection (RCMAP) Fractional Component Time-Series Across Western North America from 1985-2024
The RCMAP (Rangeland Condition Monitoring Assessment and Projection) dataset quantifies the percent cover of rangeland components across western North America using Landsat imagery from 1985-2024. The RCMAP product suite consists of ten fractional components: annual herbaceous, bare ground, herbaceous, litter, non-sagebrush shrub, perennial herbaceous, sagebrush, shrub, tree, and shrub...
Vegetation and soil cover data for long-term monitoring plots within Browns Park National Wildlife Refuge, Colorado, USA Vegetation and soil cover data for long-term monitoring plots within Browns Park National Wildlife Refuge, Colorado, USA
Sixty-eight monitoring plots within the Browns Park National Wildlife refuge in Northwest Colorado were surveyed in the Summer of 2007 and 2021 for vegetation-community changes after grazing cessation in 1986. Surveys consisted of line-point intercept measurements at 0.5m intervals along three 15-m transects arranged in a spoke around plot center at each plot location.