Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Fault fictions: Systematic biases in the conceptualization of fault-zone architecture

December 16, 2019

Mental models are a human's internal representation of the real world and have an important role in the way we understand and reason about uncertainties, explore potential options and make decisions. Mental models have not yet received much attention in geosciences, yet systematic biases can affect any geological investigation: from how the problem is conceived, through selection of appropriate hypotheses and data collection/processing methods, to the conceptualization and communication of results. We draw on findings from cognitive science and system dynamics, with knowledge and experiences of field geology, to consider the limitations and biases presented by mental models in geoscience, and their effect on predictions of the physical properties of faults in particular. We highlight biases specific to geological investigations and propose strategies for debiasing. Doing so will enhance how multiple data sources can be brought together, and minimize controllable geological uncertainty to develop more robust geological models. Critically, there is a need for standardized procedures that guard against biases, permitting data from multiple studies to be combined and communication of assumptions to be made. While we use faults to illustrate potential biases in mental models and the implications of these biases, our findings can be applied across the geosciences.

Citation Information

Publication Year 2020
Title Fault fictions: Systematic biases in the conceptualization of fault-zone architecture
DOI 10.1144/SP496-2018-161
Authors Zoe K Shipton, Jennifer J Roberts, Comrie Emma L, Yannick Kremer, Rebecca J Lunn, Jonathan Caine
Publication Type Article
Publication Subtype Journal Article
Series Title Special Publications
Index ID 70219115
Record Source USGS Publications Warehouse
USGS Organization Geology, Geophysics, and Geochemistry Science Center