The interface between rare plant management and genetics: Conserving Pitcher’s thistle (Cirsium pitcheri) in the Great Lakes region, USA

Background and Aims

Tools showing best conservation practices are becoming critical for rare plant conservation as populations become isolated through habitat fragmentation and changing ecosystem processes. We illustrate the importance of reintroduction and assisted gene flow, using reintroduction of the USA federally threatened Pitcher’s thistle (Cirsium pitcheri), a monocarpic perennial endemic to the western Great Lakes sand dunes. We evaluate the success of experimental reintroductions of this species into its dynamic coastal environment and address fundamental issues for rare plant reintroduction, including questions of maintenance of genetic diversity, founder size, introduction methods and assisted gene flow effectiveness.

Methods

In 1994 we initiated experimental reintroductions at three new locations along a habitat successional gradient using 4200 seeds collected from 54 maternal lines. At each site, seed sources were distributed among replicate blocks that were split by sowing method (sowing vs broadcasting) to examine establishment success. We monitored population demography for 30 years, assessing genetic variation in 2009 and regionally from 1997 to 2014.

Key Results

Two of three populations persisted for 30 years from a single-seeding founder event. Reintroduction populations had greater expected heterozygosity than regional native populations. Despite persistence, moderate inbreeding coefficients showed that reintroduction populations have not achieved an effective size to reduce the likelihood of inbreeding depression. However, the mid-successional reintroduction had the lowest kinship of all populations sampled, indicating a healthy restoration. Seed sowing produced three times as many seedlings as broadcasting, but seed source did not affect germination success. Persistence has been facilitated by local migration to suitable habitat patches, an important metapopulation process.

Conclusions

Seeds can be an effective method for reintroducing monocarpic plants in high-quality habitats. However, low numbers of reproductive adults and moderate inbreeding illustrate the need for repeated additions of plants or seed to reduce inbreeding to improve rare plant genetic evolutionary potential.