Are fire regimes the result of top-down or bottom-up drivers?

The evolutionary topic we examine here is whether species determine the environment (bottom-up) or if environments shape plant traits (top-down). For the environment, we focus on the fire regime. Many forests are subject to either frequent low-intensity surface fires or less frequent but high-intensity crown fires. What are the ultimate factors controlling these fire regimes? The top-down model proposes that environmental factors controlling productivity and ignitions shape fire regimes; the bottom-up model attributes them to different plant assemblies. In boreal forests, it is assumed that, because of the similar climate, forests of North America and Eurasia undergo distinct fire regimes (crown-fire and surface-fire regimes, respectively) due to bottom-up forces. We tested the hypothesis that fire regimes are primarily controlled by top-down factors by selecting congeneric species of Pinus and Picea from both continents. Plots dominated by each species were studied using remote sensing data. We then compared environmental conditions where the species occur and found that Eurasian tree species occur in warmer and more productive environments than North American tree species. Our results support the top-down model, which suggests that environmental factors control the surface- versus crown-fire regime in boreal forests.