Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Efficiently estimating salmon escapement uncertainty using systematically sampled data

January 1, 2007

Fish escapement is generally monitored using nonreplicated systematic sampling designs (e.g., via visual counts from towers or hydroacoustic counts). These sampling designs support a variety of methods for estimating the variance of the total escapement. Unfortunately, all the methods give biased results, with the magnitude of the bias being determined by the underlying process patterns. Fish escapement commonly exhibits positive autocorrelation and nonlinear patterns, such as diurnal and seasonal patterns. For these patterns, poor choice of variance estimator can needlessly increase the uncertainty managers have to deal with in sustaining fish populations. We illustrate the effect of sampling design and variance estimator choice on variance estimates of total escapement for anadromous salmonids from systematic samples of fish passage. Using simulated tower counts of sockeye salmon Oncorhynchus nerka escapement on the Kvichak River, Alaska, five variance estimators for nonreplicated systematic samples were compared to determine the least biased. Using the least biased variance estimator, four confidence interval estimators were compared for expected coverage and mean interval width. Finally, five systematic sampling designs were compared to determine the design giving the smallest average variance estimate for total annual escapement. For nonreplicated systematic samples of fish escapement, all variance estimators were positively biased. Compared to the other estimators, the least biased estimator reduced bias by, on average, from 12% to 98%. All confidence intervals gave effectively identical results. Replicated systematic sampling designs consistently provided the smallest average estimated variance among those compared.

Citation Information

Publication Year 2007
Title Efficiently estimating salmon escapement uncertainty using systematically sampled data
DOI
Authors Joel H. Reynolds, Carol Ann Woody, Nancy E. Gove, Lowell F. Fair
Publication Type Article
Publication Subtype Journal Article
Series Title American Fisheries Society Symposium
Series Number
Index ID 70174197
Record Source USGS Publications Warehouse
USGS Organization Alaska Science Center