Draining mine tunnels contribute metals and acidity to streams throughout the western United States. One remediation strategy that is increasing in usage is the emplacement of hydraulic bulkheads to impound water within the subsurface. Potential secondary effects of bulkhead usage are difficult to quantify however because of the inherent complexity of most mountain hydrologic systems.
In cooperation with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) is working to investigate processes controlling groundwater flow and acid mine drainage (AMD) geochemistry in several locations with hydraulic bulkheading. This research assists in understanding the potential efficacy of the bulkhead remediation strategy at other locations within the western United States.
In order to gain understanding of the hydrologic and geochemical processes occurring in the subsurface, the USGS collects water-quality data from draining mines, groundwater wells, and springs. A comprehensive suite of water-quality parameters is utilized including trace metals, rare earth elements (REE), stable isotopes, tritium, carbon-14, and noble gases. These water-quality data are paired with hydrologic evaluation of the groundwater-flow regime to quantify hydrological and geochemical processes affecting water quality in flooded mine workings, which can inform remedial decisions.
Results
Results from the Captain Jack mine site, located west of Boulder, Colorado, indicated that the groundwater system is disconnected and that the water within the mine workings has very little connection to the groundwater in the adjacent bedrock. Extremely high hydraulic gradients are maintained between the bedrock and mine groundwaters, even when water is impounded within the mine workings (see figure below).
Based on stable isotopes and groundwater age indicators it appears that old groundwater sustains high metal concentrations flowing into the impounded mine water and that sulfide oxidation (the process that generates AMD) can still occur when the workings are flooded (see figure below).
Related Links
EPA Superfund Site: Captain Jack Mill, Ward, CO - https://cumulis.epa.gov/supercpad/cursites/csitinfo.cfm?id=0800892
Geochemistry, mineralogy, and acid-generating behaviour of efflorescent sulphate salts in underground mines in Nevada, USA - https://doi.org/10.1144/geochem2018-074
Analytic-element groundwater-flow model of the Captain Jack Superfund Site, Boulder County, Colorado
Hydrologic and Geochemical Data and Models Supporting Integrated Evaluation of the Captain Jack Superfund Site, Boulder County, Colorado
Mechanisms of water-rock interaction and implications for remediating flooded mine workings elucidated from environmental tracers, stable isotopes, and rare earth elements
Hydrologic compartmentalization and analytic-element groundwater-flow simulations for a draining mine tunnel
Opportunities to improve water quality during abandoned mine-tunnel reclamation
- Overview
Draining mine tunnels contribute metals and acidity to streams throughout the western United States. One remediation strategy that is increasing in usage is the emplacement of hydraulic bulkheads to impound water within the subsurface. Potential secondary effects of bulkhead usage are difficult to quantify however because of the inherent complexity of most mountain hydrologic systems.
In cooperation with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) is working to investigate processes controlling groundwater flow and acid mine drainage (AMD) geochemistry in several locations with hydraulic bulkheading. This research assists in understanding the potential efficacy of the bulkhead remediation strategy at other locations within the western United States.
In order to gain understanding of the hydrologic and geochemical processes occurring in the subsurface, the USGS collects water-quality data from draining mines, groundwater wells, and springs. A comprehensive suite of water-quality parameters is utilized including trace metals, rare earth elements (REE), stable isotopes, tritium, carbon-14, and noble gases. These water-quality data are paired with hydrologic evaluation of the groundwater-flow regime to quantify hydrological and geochemical processes affecting water quality in flooded mine workings, which can inform remedial decisions.
Results
Results from the Captain Jack mine site, located west of Boulder, Colorado, indicated that the groundwater system is disconnected and that the water within the mine workings has very little connection to the groundwater in the adjacent bedrock. Extremely high hydraulic gradients are maintained between the bedrock and mine groundwaters, even when water is impounded within the mine workings (see figure below).
Groundwater level elevations within the mine workings (indicated by the red dotted lines) and within crystalline bedrock outside the mine workings (indicated by the blue dotted lines) are substantially different from one another. These vertical and horizontal gradients in groundwater level elevations indicates that the hydrologic system is highly compartmentalized and that there is little connectivity between the mine water and nearby groundwater. Although the water levels increased substantially following closure of the bulkhead (in May 2018) there was still little communication between the adjacent groundwater and the mine water (Newman, 2023). Based on stable isotopes and groundwater age indicators it appears that old groundwater sustains high metal concentrations flowing into the impounded mine water and that sulfide oxidation (the process that generates AMD) can still occur when the workings are flooded (see figure below).
Insights gained from stable isotopes and environmental tracers in this study allow a conceptual model to be built that provides information pertinent to groundwater mixing and transport, sulfide oxidation mechanisms, and timeframes of remediation. This conceptual model of the site (not to scale) is based on hydrologic and geochemical data. Piston flow and dispersion flow are denoted using different symbolized arrows. Groundwater residence time (τGW) and residence time in the workings (τW) are differentiated. A conceptual cross-sectional plot of relative intensity of sulfide oxidation, physical groundwater connectivity, and groundwater age mixing is shown on the bottom (Newman and others, 2023). Related Links
EPA Superfund Site: Captain Jack Mill, Ward, CO - https://cumulis.epa.gov/supercpad/cursites/csitinfo.cfm?id=0800892
Geochemistry, mineralogy, and acid-generating behaviour of efflorescent sulphate salts in underground mines in Nevada, USA - https://doi.org/10.1144/geochem2018-074
- Data
Analytic-element groundwater-flow model of the Captain Jack Superfund Site, Boulder County, Colorado
The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) used an analytic-element method (AEM) modeling approach to quantitatively understand groundwater dynamics at the Captain Jack Superfund Site, located in Boulder County, Colorado. The Captain Jack Superfund Site hosts extensive interconnected underground mine workings.The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has instituted a remedial strategy of impounding water wiHydrologic and Geochemical Data and Models Supporting Integrated Evaluation of the Captain Jack Superfund Site, Boulder County, Colorado
The Captain Jack Superfund site near Ward, Colorado hosts extensive interconnected underground mine workings, which drain via the Big Five Adit. Drainage from the adit has historically been acidic with elevated concentrations of metals. In 2018 the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) utilized a subsurface remediation strategy consisting of the installation of a hydraulic bulkhead within the - Multimedia
- Publications
Mechanisms of water-rock interaction and implications for remediating flooded mine workings elucidated from environmental tracers, stable isotopes, and rare earth elements
Contamination from acid mine drainage affects ecosystems and usability of groundwater for domestic and municipal purposes. The Captain Jack Superfund Site outside of Ward, Boulder County, Colorado, USA, hosts a draining mine adit that was remediated through emplacement of a hydraulic bulkhead to preclude acid mine drainage from entering nearby Lefthand Creek. During impoundment of water within theAuthorsConnor P. Newman, Katherine Walton-Day, Robert L. Runkel, Richard WilkinHydrologic compartmentalization and analytic-element groundwater-flow simulations for a draining mine tunnel
Draining mine tunnels contribute contaminants to groundwater and surface water, but remediation strategies may be hindered as hydrogeologic characterization and modeling of these heterogeneous features generally relies on sparse data sets. The Captain Jack mine site in Colorado, USA, presents a unique data set allowing for temporal evaluation of groundwater connectivity in the vicinity of an abandAuthorsConnor P. NewmanOpportunities to improve water quality during abandoned mine-tunnel reclamation
In the western United States, bulkheads are constructed to limit drainage from abandoned, draining mine adits and to protect downstream resources from uncontrolled releases of degraded adit water. Although bulkheads improve safety and water-quality conditions at the mouth of the adit, elevated hydraulic pressure behind the bulkhead often causes continuing water-quality problems in new locations. SAuthorsKatherine Walton-Day, James J. Gusek, Connor P. Newman - Partners