Selenium (Se) as a contaminant of ecosystems is bioaccumulative and causes reproductive effects in fish and wildlife. Ecosystem-scale Se modeling predicts Se bioaccumulation based on dietary biodynamics within site-specific food webs. The model can be used to forecast Se toxicity under different management or regulatory proposals or to translate a tissue guideline to a dissolved guideline.
Selenium Ecotoxicity
Selenium is recognized as an important contaminant in aquatic environments because of its potency as a reproductive toxin and its ability to bioaccumulate through food webs. Selenium's role is well documented in local extinctions of fish populations and occurrences of deformities of aquatic birds in affected habitats. Details of general ecotoxicological pathways of selenium for fish and birds and effects of concern for selenium are shown in Figure 1.
Toxicity arises when dissolved selenium is transformed to organic-selenium by bacteria, algae, fungi, and plants (i.e., synthesis of selenium-containing amino acids de novo) and then passed through food webs. It is generally thought that animals are unable to biochemically distinguish selenium from sulfur, and therefore excess selenium is substituted into proteins and alters their structure and function. Other biochemical reactions also can determine and mediate toxicity. The effect of these reactions is recorded, most importantly in birds and fish, as failures in hatching or proper development (teratogenesis or larval deformities) (Figure 1). Other toxicity endpoints include growth, winter survival, maintenance of body condition, reproductive fitness, and susceptibility to disease.
Specifically for selenium in aquatic ecosystems: (1) water-column selenium has proven to be an imprecise predictor of selenium bioaccumulated in food webs because dietary selenium makes up 95% of tissue selenium in invertebrates and fish; (2) site-specific biogeochemical transformation of dissolved selenium into particulate forms (algae, microbes, seston, or sediments) determines the concentration of selenium available at the base of food webs; (3) a 38-fold variability in trophic transfer of particulate-material selenium to invertebrate species is mainly driven by physiological differences in assimilation efficiency and the rate constant of loss of selenium among invertebrates species; and (4) dietary transfer of invertebrate selenium to fish species (as measured in whole-body tissue) has a median of approximately 1, which reflects preservation of selenium as it passes up food webs but with little increase over the trophic level below. Less information is available concerning dietary selenium biodynamics of aquatic birds, but a bird species' dietary choice of prey and the bioaccumulation kinetics of that prey are still fundamental to their exposure (as measured in bird eggs). Overall, this differential response to selenium makes some predator species more vulnerable and, thus, more likely to experience demographic collapse from moderately contaminated environments than others.
Ecosystem-Scale Selenium Modeling
The main route of exposure for selenium is dietary, yet regulations lack biologically based protocols for evaluations of risk. Ecosystem-scale selenium modeling conceptualizes and quantifies the variables that determine how selenium is processed from water through diet to predators (Figure 2). This approach uses biogeochemical and physiological factors from laboratory and field studies and considers loading, speciation, transformation to particulate material, bioavailability, bioaccumulation in invertebrates, and trophic transfer to predators. Validation of the model is through data sets from 29 historic and recent field case studies of selenium-exposed sites.
The model (Figure 2) links selenium concentrations across media (water, particulate, tissue of different food-web species). It can be used to forecast toxicity under different management or regulatory proposals or as a methodology for translating a fish-tissue (or other predator tissue) selenium concentration guideline to a dissolved selenium concentration. The model illustrates some critical aspects of implementing a tissue criterion: 1) the choice of fish species determines the food web through which selenium should be modeled, 2) the choice of food web is critical because the particulate material to prey kinetics of bioaccumulation differs widely among invertebrates, 3) the characterization of the type and phase of particulate material is important to quantifying selenium exposure to prey through the base of the food web, and 4) the metric describing partitioning between particulate material and dissolved selenium concentrations allows determination of a site-specific dissolved selenium concentration that would be responsible for that fish body burden in the specific environment.
The linked approach illustrates that environmentally safe dissolved selenium concentrations will differ among ecosystems depending on the ecological pathways and biogeochemical conditions in that system (Figure 3). Uncertainties and model sensitivities can be directly illustrated by varying exposure scenarios based on site-specific knowledge. The model can also be used to facilitate site-specific regulation and to present generic comparisons to illustrate limitations imposed by ecosystem setting and inhabitants. Used optimally, the model provides a tool for framing a site-specific ecological problem or occurrence of selenium exposure, quantify exposure within that ecosystem, and narrow uncertainties about how to protect it by understanding the specifics of the underlying system ecology, biogeochemistry, and hydrology.
References
Ecosystem-scale selenium modeling methodology:
Chapman, P.M., Adams, W.J., Brooks, M.L., Delos, C.G., Luoma, S.N., Maher, W.A., Ohlendorf, H.M., Presser, T.S., and Shaw, D.P., eds., 2010, Ecological Assessment of Selenium in the Aquatic Environment: Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) Press, Pensacola Florida, 339 p.
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2010, A Methodology for ecosystem-scale modeling of selenium: Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management, v. 6, no. 4, p. 685-710.
Luoma, S.N., and Presser, T.S., 2009, Emerging opportunities in management of selenium contamination: Environmental Science and Technology, v. 43, no. 22, p. 8483-8487.
Luoma, S.N., and Rainbow, P.S., 2005, Why is metal bioaccumulation so variable? Biodynamics as a unifying concept: Environmental Science and Technology, 39:1925–1931.
In-depth publications for site-specific application of ecosystem-scale selenium modeling:
Luoma, S.N., and Presser, T.S., 2018, Status of selenium in south San Francisco Bay—A basis for modeling potential guidelines to meet National tissue criteria for fish and a proposed wildlife criterion for birds: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2018–1105, 75 p.
Presser, T.S., and Naftz, D.L., 2018, USGS Measurements of Dissolved and Suspended Particulate Material Selenium in Lake Koocanusa in the Vicinity of Libby Dam (MT), 2015-2017 (update): U.S. Geological Survey data release.
Presser, T.S., and Naftz, D.L., 2017, USGS Measurements of Dissolved and Suspended Particulate Material Selenium in Lake Koocanusa in the Vicinity of Libby Dam (MT), 2015-2016: U.S. Geological Survey data release.
Jenni, K.E., Naftz, D.L., Naftz, Presser, T.S., 2017, Conceptual Modeling Framework to Support Development of Site-Specific Selenium Criteria for Lake Koocanusa, Montana, U.S.A., and British Columbia, Canada: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2017-1130, 14 p.
Presser, T.S., 2013, Selenium in Ecosystems within the Mountaintop Coal Mining and Valley-Fill Region of Southern West Virginia-Assessment and Ecosystem-Scale Modeling, U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1803, 86 p.
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2013, Ecosystem-scale selenium model for the San Francisco Bay-Delta Regional Ecosystem Restoration Implementation Plan (DRERIP): San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science, v. 11, no. 1, p. 1-39.
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2010, Ecosystem-scale selenium modeling in support of fish and wildlife selenium criteria development for the San Francisco Bay-Delta Estuary, California: U.S. Geological Survey Administrative Report, 101 p. and Appendices A-D. [Published 12/14/2010; released by USEPA (Region 9, San Francisco, California) 8/29/2011]
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2009, Modeling of selenium for the San Diego Creek watershed and Newport Bay, California: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2009-1114, 48 p.
Below are other science projects associated with the Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems project.
Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Local and Global Perspectives
Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Mining
Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Irrigation
Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Refining
Below are publications associated with the Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems project.
Status of selenium in south San Francisco Bay—A basis for modeling potential guidelines to meet National tissue criteria for fish and a proposed wildlife criterion for birds
Conceptual modeling framework to support development of site-specific selenium criteria for Lake Koocanusa, Montana, U.S.A., and British Columbia, Canada
Selenium in ecosystems within the mountaintop coal mining and valley-fill region of southern West Virginia-assessment and ecosystem-scale modeling
A methodology for ecosystem-scale modeling of selenium
Modeling of selenium for the San Diego Creek watershed and Newport Bay, California
Why is metal bioaccumulation so variable? Biodynamics as a unifying concept
- Overview
Selenium (Se) as a contaminant of ecosystems is bioaccumulative and causes reproductive effects in fish and wildlife. Ecosystem-scale Se modeling predicts Se bioaccumulation based on dietary biodynamics within site-specific food webs. The model can be used to forecast Se toxicity under different management or regulatory proposals or to translate a tissue guideline to a dissolved guideline.
Selenium Ecotoxicity
Selenium is recognized as an important contaminant in aquatic environments because of its potency as a reproductive toxin and its ability to bioaccumulate through food webs. Selenium's role is well documented in local extinctions of fish populations and occurrences of deformities of aquatic birds in affected habitats. Details of general ecotoxicological pathways of selenium for fish and birds and effects of concern for selenium are shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Details of 1) general ecotoxicological pathways of selenium for fish and birds; and 2) effects of concern for selenium. As represented here, birds and fish differ in how selenium taken up from diet distributes among tissues. Toxicity arises when dissolved selenium is transformed to organic-selenium by bacteria, algae, fungi, and plants (i.e., synthesis of selenium-containing amino acids de novo) and then passed through food webs. It is generally thought that animals are unable to biochemically distinguish selenium from sulfur, and therefore excess selenium is substituted into proteins and alters their structure and function. Other biochemical reactions also can determine and mediate toxicity. The effect of these reactions is recorded, most importantly in birds and fish, as failures in hatching or proper development (teratogenesis or larval deformities) (Figure 1). Other toxicity endpoints include growth, winter survival, maintenance of body condition, reproductive fitness, and susceptibility to disease.
Specifically for selenium in aquatic ecosystems: (1) water-column selenium has proven to be an imprecise predictor of selenium bioaccumulated in food webs because dietary selenium makes up 95% of tissue selenium in invertebrates and fish; (2) site-specific biogeochemical transformation of dissolved selenium into particulate forms (algae, microbes, seston, or sediments) determines the concentration of selenium available at the base of food webs; (3) a 38-fold variability in trophic transfer of particulate-material selenium to invertebrate species is mainly driven by physiological differences in assimilation efficiency and the rate constant of loss of selenium among invertebrates species; and (4) dietary transfer of invertebrate selenium to fish species (as measured in whole-body tissue) has a median of approximately 1, which reflects preservation of selenium as it passes up food webs but with little increase over the trophic level below. Less information is available concerning dietary selenium biodynamics of aquatic birds, but a bird species' dietary choice of prey and the bioaccumulation kinetics of that prey are still fundamental to their exposure (as measured in bird eggs). Overall, this differential response to selenium makes some predator species more vulnerable and, thus, more likely to experience demographic collapse from moderately contaminated environments than others.
Ecosystem-Scale Selenium Modeling
The main route of exposure for selenium is dietary, yet regulations lack biologically based protocols for evaluations of risk. Ecosystem-scale selenium modeling conceptualizes and quantifies the variables that determine how selenium is processed from water through diet to predators (Figure 2). This approach uses biogeochemical and physiological factors from laboratory and field studies and considers loading, speciation, transformation to particulate material, bioavailability, bioaccumulation in invertebrates, and trophic transfer to predators. Validation of the model is through data sets from 29 historic and recent field case studies of selenium-exposed sites.
Figure 2. Ecosystem-scale selenium modeling conceptualizes processes and parameters important for quantifying and understanding the effects of selenium in the environment. The model can be applied to forecast exposure and to evaluate the implications of management or regulatory choices. Kd = empirically determined environmental partitioning factor between water and particulate material; TTF = biodynamic food-web transfer factor between an animal and its food. The model (Figure 2) links selenium concentrations across media (water, particulate, tissue of different food-web species). It can be used to forecast toxicity under different management or regulatory proposals or as a methodology for translating a fish-tissue (or other predator tissue) selenium concentration guideline to a dissolved selenium concentration. The model illustrates some critical aspects of implementing a tissue criterion: 1) the choice of fish species determines the food web through which selenium should be modeled, 2) the choice of food web is critical because the particulate material to prey kinetics of bioaccumulation differs widely among invertebrates, 3) the characterization of the type and phase of particulate material is important to quantifying selenium exposure to prey through the base of the food web, and 4) the metric describing partitioning between particulate material and dissolved selenium concentrations allows determination of a site-specific dissolved selenium concentration that would be responsible for that fish body burden in the specific environment.
The linked approach illustrates that environmentally safe dissolved selenium concentrations will differ among ecosystems depending on the ecological pathways and biogeochemical conditions in that system (Figure 3). Uncertainties and model sensitivities can be directly illustrated by varying exposure scenarios based on site-specific knowledge. The model can also be used to facilitate site-specific regulation and to present generic comparisons to illustrate limitations imposed by ecosystem setting and inhabitants. Used optimally, the model provides a tool for framing a site-specific ecological problem or occurrence of selenium exposure, quantify exposure within that ecosystem, and narrow uncertainties about how to protect it by understanding the specifics of the underlying system ecology, biogeochemistry, and hydrology.
Figure 3. Quantitative outcomes from applying ecosystem-scale selenium modeling to various environmental exposure scenarios. Hydrologic environment types include an estuary, reservoir, mainstream river, backwater, saline lake, and a wetland. Food webs illustrate invertebrates as prey and fish or birds as predators. Additional food-web steps can be added to illustrate more complex food webs (e.g., invertebrate through fish to bird or to include forage fish to predatory fish). References
Ecosystem-scale selenium modeling methodology:
Chapman, P.M., Adams, W.J., Brooks, M.L., Delos, C.G., Luoma, S.N., Maher, W.A., Ohlendorf, H.M., Presser, T.S., and Shaw, D.P., eds., 2010, Ecological Assessment of Selenium in the Aquatic Environment: Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) Press, Pensacola Florida, 339 p.
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2010, A Methodology for ecosystem-scale modeling of selenium: Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management, v. 6, no. 4, p. 685-710.
Luoma, S.N., and Presser, T.S., 2009, Emerging opportunities in management of selenium contamination: Environmental Science and Technology, v. 43, no. 22, p. 8483-8487.
Luoma, S.N., and Rainbow, P.S., 2005, Why is metal bioaccumulation so variable? Biodynamics as a unifying concept: Environmental Science and Technology, 39:1925–1931.
In-depth publications for site-specific application of ecosystem-scale selenium modeling:
Luoma, S.N., and Presser, T.S., 2018, Status of selenium in south San Francisco Bay—A basis for modeling potential guidelines to meet National tissue criteria for fish and a proposed wildlife criterion for birds: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2018–1105, 75 p.
Presser, T.S., and Naftz, D.L., 2018, USGS Measurements of Dissolved and Suspended Particulate Material Selenium in Lake Koocanusa in the Vicinity of Libby Dam (MT), 2015-2017 (update): U.S. Geological Survey data release.
Presser, T.S., and Naftz, D.L., 2017, USGS Measurements of Dissolved and Suspended Particulate Material Selenium in Lake Koocanusa in the Vicinity of Libby Dam (MT), 2015-2016: U.S. Geological Survey data release.
Jenni, K.E., Naftz, D.L., Naftz, Presser, T.S., 2017, Conceptual Modeling Framework to Support Development of Site-Specific Selenium Criteria for Lake Koocanusa, Montana, U.S.A., and British Columbia, Canada: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2017-1130, 14 p.
Presser, T.S., 2013, Selenium in Ecosystems within the Mountaintop Coal Mining and Valley-Fill Region of Southern West Virginia-Assessment and Ecosystem-Scale Modeling, U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1803, 86 p.
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2013, Ecosystem-scale selenium model for the San Francisco Bay-Delta Regional Ecosystem Restoration Implementation Plan (DRERIP): San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science, v. 11, no. 1, p. 1-39.
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2010, Ecosystem-scale selenium modeling in support of fish and wildlife selenium criteria development for the San Francisco Bay-Delta Estuary, California: U.S. Geological Survey Administrative Report, 101 p. and Appendices A-D. [Published 12/14/2010; released by USEPA (Region 9, San Francisco, California) 8/29/2011]
Presser, T.S., and Luoma, S.N., 2009, Modeling of selenium for the San Diego Creek watershed and Newport Bay, California: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2009-1114, 48 p.
- Science
Below are other science projects associated with the Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems project.
Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Local and Global Perspectives
The sources, biogeochemistry, and ecotoxicology of selenium (Se) combine to produce a widespread potential for ecological risk such as deformities in birds and fish. Linking the understanding of source characteristics to a mechanistic, biodynamic dietary model of Se exposure on an ecosystem-scale improves the prediction of Se effects and its potential remediation.Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Mining
Environmental sources of selenium (Se) such as from organic-enriched sedimentary deposits are geologic in nature and thus can occur on regional scales. A constructed map of the global distribution of Se source rocks informs potential areas of reconnaissance for modeling of Se risk including the phosphate deposits of southeastern Idaho and the coals of Appalachia.Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Irrigation
Adverse effects of selenium (Se) on fish and waterfowl in wetlands receiving agricultural drainage occurred in the 1980s in the San Joaquin Valley of California. The identified mechanisms of Se enrichment helped resolve Se toxicity problems associated with irrigated agriculture in the arid West. Bioaccumulation of Se in ancient marine sediments is postulated as a primary pathway in source rocks.Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems: Refining
The San Francisco Bay-Delta receives selenium (Se) internally from oil refineries and externally through riverine agricultural discharges. Predator species considered at risk from Se consume the estuary’s dominant bivalve, C. amurensis, an efficient bioaccumulator of Se. Modeling predicts site-specific ecological risk and derives a range of protective Se concentrations for use by decision-makers. - Publications
Below are publications associated with the Linking Selenium Sources to Ecosystems project.
Status of selenium in south San Francisco Bay—A basis for modeling potential guidelines to meet National tissue criteria for fish and a proposed wildlife criterion for birds
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposed Aquatic Life and AquaticDependent Wildlife Criteria for Selenium (Se) in California’s San Francisco Bay and Delta (Bay-Delta) in June 2016. Here we apply the same modeling methodology—Ecosystem-Scale Selenium Modeling— to an assessment of conditions and documentation of food webs of south San Francisco Bay (South Bay) as an exploratory framewConceptual modeling framework to support development of site-specific selenium criteria for Lake Koocanusa, Montana, U.S.A., and British Columbia, Canada
The U.S. Geological Survey, working with the Montana Department of Environmental Quality and the British Columbia Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change Strategy, has developed a conceptual modeling framework that can be used to provide structured and scientifically based input to the Lake Koocanusa Monitoring and Research Working Group as they consider potential site-specific selenium criSelenium in ecosystems within the mountaintop coal mining and valley-fill region of southern West Virginia-assessment and ecosystem-scale modeling
Coal and associated waste rock are among environmental selenium (Se) sources that have the potential to affect reproduction in fish and aquatic birds. Ecosystems of southern West Virginia that are affected by drainage from mountaintop coal mines and valleys filled with waste rock in the Coal, Gauley, and Lower Guyandotte watersheds were assessed during 2010 and 2011. Sampling data from earlier stuA methodology for ecosystem-scale modeling of selenium
The main route of exposure for selenium (Se) is dietary, yet regulations lack biologically based protocols for evaluations of risk. We propose here an ecosystem-scale model that conceptualizes and quantifies the variables that determinehow Se is processed from water through diet to predators. This approach uses biogeochemical and physiological factors from laboratory and field studies and considerModeling of selenium for the San Diego Creek watershed and Newport Bay, California
The San Diego Creek watershed and Newport Bay in southern California are contaminated with selenium (Se) as a result of groundwater associated with urban development overlying a historical wetland, the Swamp of the Frogs. The primary Se source is drainage from surrounding seleniferous marine sedimentary formations. An ecosystem-scale model was employed as a tool to assist development of a site-speWhy is metal bioaccumulation so variable? Biodynamics as a unifying concept
Ecological risks from metal contaminants are difficult to document because responses differ among species, threats differ among metals, and environmental influences are complex. Unifying concepts are needed to better tie together such complexities. Here we suggest that a biologically based conceptualization, the biodynamic model, provides the necessary unification for a key aspect in risk: metal