Oil and gas development across the western United States has increased substantially in recent decades, including within the Colorado Plateau. The Colorado Plateau is a high desert region of grasslands, shrublands, and woodlands and is home to a large number of world-renowned national and tribal parks and monuments (e.g., Grand Canyon, Zion, Bryce, Arches, Canyonlands, Monument Valley, and Mesa Verde). Energy development on the Colorado Plateau is of concern regionally due to potential environmental impacts, including water and air pollution, habitat fragmentation, dust emissions, and soil loss from erosion, all of which can have cascading impacts on human health. Oil and gas well pads are often developed and then abandoned when they are no longer sufficiently productive. However, the rate and degree of recovery of these abandoned sites to a relatively natural state remains unclear.
The Soil-Adjusted Total Vegetation Index (SATVI), calculated using the red and shortwave infrared (SWIR) bands from Landsat, provides consistent estimates of total vegetation cover in drylands, and is used to assess pad changes over time. We develop dense time series (1984-2011) of Landsat SATVI on abandoned well pads as well as nearby control areas of similar environmental conditions, which helped to standardize the assessment. The statistical package Breaks For Additive Season and Trend (BFAST) was used to identify breaks in the time series related to initial site disturbance and active pad use, and to quantify the magnitude, duration, and rate of vegetation change after abandonment. We analyzed change rates relative to climate and other spatial variables and found vegetation increases are most strongly related to wet and cool conditions of winter-spring months during the year of abandonment. However, high-resolution aerial imagery and Landsat-based phenology indices indicate that many abandoned pads where vegetation increased over time are dominated by exotic grasses and annual plants.
Future work: We are currently developing SATVI time series for a smaller subset of well pads that have been reclaimed relatively recently (ca. >2000) such that the pad management reflects modern methods, including recontouring, saving and spreading topsoil, addressing soil contamination, and seeding. We are working closely with BLM to select sample sites based on known pad history and reclamation practices used (dates, seed mixes, application, and others). A subsample of pads will be selected for extensive field data collection of vegetation and soil information.
Below are data or web applications associated with this project.
Geodatabase of oil and gas pads and roads within the Bureau of Land Management's Carlsbad Field Office administrative boundary, New Mexico
5-year Relative Fractional Vegetation Cover at Abandoned Energy Development Sites on the Colorado Plateau
Grassland State and Transition Map of Canyonlands National Park Needles District and Indian Creek Grazing Allotment
Below are publications associated with this project.
Time, climate, and soil settings set the course for reclamation outcomes following dryland energy development
Landsat time series assessment of invasive annual grasses following energy development
Landsat time series analysis of fractional plant cover changes on abandoned energy development sites
Identifying optimal remotely-sensed variables for ecosystem monitoring in Colorado Plateau drylands
Disturbance automated reference toolset (DART): Assessing patterns in ecological recovery from energy development on the Colorado Plateau
Below are news stories associated with this project.
- Overview
Oil and gas development across the western United States has increased substantially in recent decades, including within the Colorado Plateau. The Colorado Plateau is a high desert region of grasslands, shrublands, and woodlands and is home to a large number of world-renowned national and tribal parks and monuments (e.g., Grand Canyon, Zion, Bryce, Arches, Canyonlands, Monument Valley, and Mesa Verde). Energy development on the Colorado Plateau is of concern regionally due to potential environmental impacts, including water and air pollution, habitat fragmentation, dust emissions, and soil loss from erosion, all of which can have cascading impacts on human health. Oil and gas well pads are often developed and then abandoned when they are no longer sufficiently productive. However, the rate and degree of recovery of these abandoned sites to a relatively natural state remains unclear.
The Soil-Adjusted Total Vegetation Index (SATVI), calculated using the red and shortwave infrared (SWIR) bands from Landsat, provides consistent estimates of total vegetation cover in drylands, and is used to assess pad changes over time. We develop dense time series (1984-2011) of Landsat SATVI on abandoned well pads as well as nearby control areas of similar environmental conditions, which helped to standardize the assessment. The statistical package Breaks For Additive Season and Trend (BFAST) was used to identify breaks in the time series related to initial site disturbance and active pad use, and to quantify the magnitude, duration, and rate of vegetation change after abandonment. We analyzed change rates relative to climate and other spatial variables and found vegetation increases are most strongly related to wet and cool conditions of winter-spring months during the year of abandonment. However, high-resolution aerial imagery and Landsat-based phenology indices indicate that many abandoned pads where vegetation increased over time are dominated by exotic grasses and annual plants.
Future work: We are currently developing SATVI time series for a smaller subset of well pads that have been reclaimed relatively recently (ca. >2000) such that the pad management reflects modern methods, including recontouring, saving and spreading topsoil, addressing soil contamination, and seeding. We are working closely with BLM to select sample sites based on known pad history and reclamation practices used (dates, seed mixes, application, and others). A subsample of pads will be selected for extensive field data collection of vegetation and soil information.
Figure 1.1.1. Density of oil and gas well pads per km2 in the Colorado Plateau ecoregion (including parts of Utah, Colorado and New Mexico) as counted in 2016. Oil/gas wells are particularly concentrated in this region with ~100,000 abandoned and current wells spanning 60 years of activity. These numbers are dramatically increasing with time. (Public domain.) Figure 1.1.2. An active oil and gas well pad and an abandoned pad being reclaimed (top left inset). Figure 1.1.3.Graph showing A) Landsat time series of the Soil-Adjusted Total Vegetation Index (SATVI) from 1984-2011. Phases include pre-drilling from 1984-2002, active from 2002-2006, and post-abandonment 2006-2011, B) Bfast model of trends used to estimate breaks in the time series, and C) orhtophotos showing the site during different points in time and where those dates fall on the Landsat time series. The rapid cover change from 2006-2009 and the appearance of dense green. Figure 1.1.4. USGS scientists visiting an old abandoned well pad site. - Data
Below are data or web applications associated with this project.
Geodatabase of oil and gas pads and roads within the Bureau of Land Management's Carlsbad Field Office administrative boundary, New Mexico
This database contains spatial data on the location, number, size and extent of energy-related surface disturbances within the Bureau of Land Management’s (BLM) Carlsbad Field Office (CFO) administrative area. The BLM administers over 2 million acres of surface estate and 3 million acres of mineral estate in the southeastern portion of New Mexico. The BLM requires a thorough and comprehensive reas5-year Relative Fractional Vegetation Cover at Abandoned Energy Development Sites on the Colorado Plateau
This data release contains a single vector shapefile and two text documents with code used to generate the data product. This vector shapefile contains the locations of 365 "plugged and abandoned" well sites from across the Colorado Plateau with their respective relative fractional vegetation cover (RFVC) values. Oil and gas pads are often developed for production, and then capped, reclaimed, anGrassland State and Transition Map of Canyonlands National Park Needles District and Indian Creek Grazing Allotment
This raster data depicts the modeled distribution of three grassland states: Biocrust, Grass-bare, and Annualized-bare. We developed models of bare ground, total vegetation, exotic grasses and biological soil crust using spectral data from three year composites of growing season (March-October) Landsat data in Google Earth Engine and field data that were collected over the same period at monitorin - Publications
Below are publications associated with this project.
Time, climate, and soil settings set the course for reclamation outcomes following dryland energy development
Soil attributes, climate, and time since reclamation have important implications for oil and gas reclamation success on drylands. It is uncertain if reclaimed well pads, on highly degraded drylands, can successfully regain ecological function or meet indicator benchmarks for reclamation. Here, our goals were to assess patterns in reclamation outcomes relative to (1) soil attributes, climate, and tAuthorsRandi Corrine Lupardus, Aarin Sengsirirak, Keven Griffen, Anna C Knight, Brandon E McNellis, John B. Bradford, Seth M. Munson, Sasha C. Reed, Miguel L. Villarreal, Michael C. DuniwayLandsat time series assessment of invasive annual grasses following energy development
Invasive annual grasses are of concern in many areas of the Western United States because they tolerate resource variability and have high reproductive capacity, with propagules that are readily dispersed in disturbed areas like those created and maintained for energy development. Early-season invasive grasses “green up” earlier than the most native plants, producing a distinct pulse of greennessAuthorsMiguel L. Villarreal, Christopher E. Soulard, Eric WallerLandsat time series analysis of fractional plant cover changes on abandoned energy development sites
Oil and natural gas development in the western United States has increased substantially in recent decades as technological advances like horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing have made extraction more commercially viable. Oil and gas pads are often developed for production, and then capped, reclaimed, and left to recover when no longer productive. Understanding the rates, controls, and degAuthorsEric K. Waller, Miguel L. Villarreal, Travis B. Poitras, Travis W. Nauman, Michael C. DuniwayIdentifying optimal remotely-sensed variables for ecosystem monitoring in Colorado Plateau drylands
Water-limited ecosystems often recover slowly following anthropogenic or natural disturbance. Multitemporal remote sensing can be used to monitor ecosystem recovery after disturbance; however, dryland vegetation cover can be challenging to accurately measure due to sparse cover and spectral confusion between soils and non-photosynthetic vegetation. With the goal of optimizing a monitoring approachAuthorsTravis B. Poitras, Miguel L. Villarreal, Eric K. Waller, Travis W. Nauman, Mark E. Miller, Michael C. DuniwayDisturbance automated reference toolset (DART): Assessing patterns in ecological recovery from energy development on the Colorado Plateau
A new disturbance automated reference toolset (DART) was developed to monitor human land surface impacts using soil-type and ecological context. DART identifies reference areas with similar soils, topography, and geology; and compares the disturbance condition to the reference area condition using a quantile-based approach based on a satellite vegetation index. DART was able to represent 26–55% ofAuthorsTravis W. Nauman, Michael C. Duniway, Miguel L. Villarreal, Travis B. Poitras - News
Below are news stories associated with this project.