Use and Evaluation of Stimuli for Herding Bigheaded Carps to Increase their Capture Efficiency
Mass removal of the invasive silver carp Hypophthalmichthys molitrix and bighead carp Hypophthalmichthys nobilis (collectively referred to as bigheaded carp) is a primary management action in the United States to contain population growth and reduce upstream dispersal. Efficient capture and removal techniques are required to achieve this goal, and the USGS is working to develop and evaluate such methods.
Fighting invasive fish with AI and unmanned kayaks: Invasive species like bighead carp are damaging wetlands and fisheries in Illinois, but a high-tech innovation could solve the problem.
The Issue:
The USGS is part of the Invasive Carp Regional Coordinating Committee (ICRCC) and is focused on the research and development of techniques that could help natural resource managers better manage and control invasive carp populations in the United States. Bigheaded carp are notoriously difficult to catch using traditional gears developed for native fish species. However, their evasive behavior and gear avoidance can be advantageous to actively move aggregations into areas where they can be efficiently removed or harvested.
Addressing the Issue:
Early work has confirmed herding bigheaded carp with acoustic stimulus (broadband) or electric stimulus is feasible to increase catch rates in entanglements nets. When utilizing these stimuli in conjunction, we found that corralling bigheaded carp into large beach seines was profoundly effective, and the implementation of this technique (i.e., the modified unified method of clearing block nets and forcing fish to a harvest location) resulted in the removal of nearly 240,000 lbs of bigheaded carp from a 300-acre reservoir in St. Louis, MO. This achievement warranted further research and refinement and thus, we initiated a rigorous field-based study to assess bigheaded carp herding effectiveness in the context of mass removal/harvest. We software edited the playback recording of the acoustic stimulus to increase noise complexity and reduce likelihood of fish habituation. We reconfigured the anode array design specifically for herding to increase voltage range (vertical and horizontal). In addition, we produced an electric goal table to ensure consistent power transfer to fish according to variable ambient conductivity of the water and manipulate movements in fish. The following herding techniques were evaluated: (1) a method commonly used by commercial fishers in the United States (trimming the propellor near the water surface and revving the motor to eject plumes of water and striking the boat hull with a blunt object), (2) electric (pulsed-DC electrofishing boat), (3) broadband acoustic (two underwater speakers), (4) both acoustic and electric in combination, and (5) solely the boat with no added stimulus (control variable). Results suggest the combination of acoustic and electric was three to four times more effective than the other techniques and repeating the herding application once more was important to further increase effectiveness. The synergy of acoustic and electric stimuli is likely advantageous to herding bigheaded carps because the acoustic stimulus alerts fish in the range of hundreds of meters from the source and deterrence is reinforced in the electrical field as the boat approaches.
We have utilized herding to manage bigheaded carps in several habitat types with the intended goal of either removal or deterrence. For example, we used herding to clear bigheaded carp out of a lock and dam chamber in coordination with the Army Corps of Engineers so it could be drained and repaired without costly delays related to handling fish. In terms of removal, large beach seins (500–2000 ft long) are generally the favorable gear type, but seining is site dependent and limited to specific environmental characteristics (i.e., zero flow, cleared of snags, and a gradual slopping shore). In contrast, large trap gears are versatile and could be advantageous to incrementally remove manageable numbers of fish rather than pulling in several thousands of pounds in a single beach seine haul. Our preliminary research suggests actively herding bigheaded carp into large trap nets (i.e., iruka net, merwin net, and pound net) is not efficient as fish had difficulty choosing to swim through trap net throats. However, bigheaded carp were receptive to capture after herding had completed and trap nets were left in place to fish passively.
Next Steps/Future Steps/Results:
Current and future work will involve developmental research to assess planning, strategy, and deployment of fish corrals and capture techniques conducive to bigheaded carp herding. In addition, sonar and telemetry-based studies will inform herding implementation and procedures including transect placement, herding speed, coverage, and replication required to achieve management objectives across a variety of habitat types and systems bigheaded carp invaded.
Return to Conservation, Quantitative, and Restoration Ecology
Return to Invasive Species Ecology
Development and Evaluation of Novel Capture Gears for Bigheaded Carps
Chemical Attractant Investigations to Increase Aggregation and Harvest for the Control of Asian Carp
Assessment of Acoustic Stimuli for Manipulating Movement of Bigheaded Carps
Mass removal of the invasive silver carp Hypophthalmichthys molitrix and bighead carp Hypophthalmichthys nobilis (collectively referred to as bigheaded carp) is a primary management action in the United States to contain population growth and reduce upstream dispersal. Efficient capture and removal techniques are required to achieve this goal, and the USGS is working to develop and evaluate such methods.
Fighting invasive fish with AI and unmanned kayaks: Invasive species like bighead carp are damaging wetlands and fisheries in Illinois, but a high-tech innovation could solve the problem.
The Issue:
The USGS is part of the Invasive Carp Regional Coordinating Committee (ICRCC) and is focused on the research and development of techniques that could help natural resource managers better manage and control invasive carp populations in the United States. Bigheaded carp are notoriously difficult to catch using traditional gears developed for native fish species. However, their evasive behavior and gear avoidance can be advantageous to actively move aggregations into areas where they can be efficiently removed or harvested.
Addressing the Issue:
Early work has confirmed herding bigheaded carp with acoustic stimulus (broadband) or electric stimulus is feasible to increase catch rates in entanglements nets. When utilizing these stimuli in conjunction, we found that corralling bigheaded carp into large beach seines was profoundly effective, and the implementation of this technique (i.e., the modified unified method of clearing block nets and forcing fish to a harvest location) resulted in the removal of nearly 240,000 lbs of bigheaded carp from a 300-acre reservoir in St. Louis, MO. This achievement warranted further research and refinement and thus, we initiated a rigorous field-based study to assess bigheaded carp herding effectiveness in the context of mass removal/harvest. We software edited the playback recording of the acoustic stimulus to increase noise complexity and reduce likelihood of fish habituation. We reconfigured the anode array design specifically for herding to increase voltage range (vertical and horizontal). In addition, we produced an electric goal table to ensure consistent power transfer to fish according to variable ambient conductivity of the water and manipulate movements in fish. The following herding techniques were evaluated: (1) a method commonly used by commercial fishers in the United States (trimming the propellor near the water surface and revving the motor to eject plumes of water and striking the boat hull with a blunt object), (2) electric (pulsed-DC electrofishing boat), (3) broadband acoustic (two underwater speakers), (4) both acoustic and electric in combination, and (5) solely the boat with no added stimulus (control variable). Results suggest the combination of acoustic and electric was three to four times more effective than the other techniques and repeating the herding application once more was important to further increase effectiveness. The synergy of acoustic and electric stimuli is likely advantageous to herding bigheaded carps because the acoustic stimulus alerts fish in the range of hundreds of meters from the source and deterrence is reinforced in the electrical field as the boat approaches.
We have utilized herding to manage bigheaded carps in several habitat types with the intended goal of either removal or deterrence. For example, we used herding to clear bigheaded carp out of a lock and dam chamber in coordination with the Army Corps of Engineers so it could be drained and repaired without costly delays related to handling fish. In terms of removal, large beach seins (500–2000 ft long) are generally the favorable gear type, but seining is site dependent and limited to specific environmental characteristics (i.e., zero flow, cleared of snags, and a gradual slopping shore). In contrast, large trap gears are versatile and could be advantageous to incrementally remove manageable numbers of fish rather than pulling in several thousands of pounds in a single beach seine haul. Our preliminary research suggests actively herding bigheaded carp into large trap nets (i.e., iruka net, merwin net, and pound net) is not efficient as fish had difficulty choosing to swim through trap net throats. However, bigheaded carp were receptive to capture after herding had completed and trap nets were left in place to fish passively.
Next Steps/Future Steps/Results:
Current and future work will involve developmental research to assess planning, strategy, and deployment of fish corrals and capture techniques conducive to bigheaded carp herding. In addition, sonar and telemetry-based studies will inform herding implementation and procedures including transect placement, herding speed, coverage, and replication required to achieve management objectives across a variety of habitat types and systems bigheaded carp invaded.
Return to Conservation, Quantitative, and Restoration Ecology
Return to Invasive Species Ecology