Complex Mixtures, Complex Responses—Using Comprehensive Approaches to Assess Pharmaceutical Effects on Fish
Science Center Objects
The occurrence of complex mixtures of prescription pharmaceuticals in streams and rivers around the globe has raised concerns about potential unintended adverse effects on aquatic organisms. The deleterious effects (for example, alteration of fish behavior) observed in this study confirm that effluents containing pharmaceuticals can adversely affect fish in ways that are central to sustaining populations and that the effects may not be temporally consistent.
Adult fathead minnows, such as this one, were exposed to treated wastewater effluent that contained pharmaceuticals to help scientists understand the effects of pharmaceuticals on fish in streams. Photo Credit: Megan Cox, St. Cloud State University.
Prescription pharmaceuticals have been found in streams and lakes throughout the United States. They enter aquatic ecosystems primarily through treated municipal wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluent following human excretion or disposal of unwanted pharmaceuticals into the sewer system. Pharmaceuticals and their transformation products are generally present in low concentrations (less than 100 nanograms per liter) in most treated municipal wastewater effluents, but according to previous U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) research, they can be locally elevated in the effluent at WWTPs that receive incoming waste from pharmaceutical formulation facilities.
The present collaborative study between St. Cloud State University and USGS scientists used a comprehensive set of biological endpoints and minnow life stages in laboratory and field exposures to better understand the effects of pharmaceuticals on larval and adult fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas). This type of minnow was chosen because they are a common laboratory model for studies of this kind and are also an ecologically important species present throughout North America.
A view of the field exposure setup where the scientists exposed both larval and adult fathead minnows to treated effluent from a wastewater treatment plant. Photo Credit: Heiko L. Schoenfuss, St. Cloud State University.
Larval and adult fathead minnows were exposed to treated municipal effluent from a WWTP known to receive input from a pharmaceutical formulation facility. In addition, both life stages were also exposed in the laboratory to the following nine pharmaceuticals individually or in mixtures: temazepam, a sleep aid; methocarbamol, a muscle relaxant; tramadol, an opioid agonist; hydrocodone, methadone, and oxycodone, opioids; and fluoxetine, paroxetine, and venlafaxine-antidepressants. The selected pharmaceuticals and corresponding exposure levels were guided by the previous USGS research.
The complexity of the effluent and laboratory exposures resulted in comparable complex biological responses. Juvenile fathead minnows exposed to the chemicals suffered from reduced growth and altered escape behavior. The altered escape behavior means that, when faced with a threat, the minnows did not escape as efficiently as they normally would, which could potentially increase the chances they would be eaten and could ultimately translate to population-level effects.
Adult fish reacted differently than juvenile fish to exposures. Adult females exposed to a mixture of the pharmaceuticals generally experienced an increase in relative liver size compared to control females, which suggests that the liver is reacting to pharmaceutical exposure. Adult males exposed to the pharmaceuticals had a variety of reactions. Most did not defend their nests as rigorously as those that were not exposed to the pharmaceuticals. The males exposed to WWTP effluent in the field component of this research produced a chemical known as plasma vitellogenin, a protein associated with egg production in females and not present in male fish under normal conditions.
This study documents that treated effluent containing pharmaceuticals and exposures to pharmaceuticals in a laboratory study can affect fish behavior and other biological endpoints. This study highlights the importance of including diverse biological endpoints spanning levels of biological organization and life stages when assessing the effects of pharmaceuticals. The environmental concentrations of prescription pharmaceuticals are usually below human or domestic animal therapeutic concentrations; however, these lower concentrations may still have effects on aquatic organisms that are exposed on a continual basis.
This study is part of a long-term effort by the USGS Toxic Substances Hydrology Program to determine the fate and effects of contaminants of emerging concern and to provide water-resource managers with objective information that assists in the development of effective water management practices. Understanding the impacts of environmental pharmaceutical occurrence in aquatic ecosystems may allow for effective strategies to reduce organism exposures.
The study was supported by the National Science Foundation (CBET 1336062) and the USGS Toxic Substances Hydrology Program.
More Information
- Pharmaceutical fish: SCSU experiments: St. Cloud Times, December 2, 2015, news story (Hypertext links and other references to non-USGS products and services are provided for information only and do not constitute endorsement or warranty by the USGS, U.S. Department of the Interior, or U.S. Government)
Related Featured Science Activities
- Gestodene Affects Fish Reproductive Behavior in Laboratory Exposure Study
- Swine Manure Application as a Source of Hepatitis E Virus and other Livestock-Related Pathogens
- Recovery of Stream and Adjacent Groundwater After Wastewater Treatment Facility Closure
- Synthetic Progestin in Environmental Waters can Affect Fish Reproductive Development and Behavior
- Landfill Leachate Released to Wastewater Treatment Plants and other Environmental Pathways Contains a Mixture of Contaminants including Pharmaceuticals
- Potential Exposure to Bacteria and Viruses Weeks after Swine Manure Spill
- Long-Term Study Finds Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals in Urban Waterways
- Assessing Environmental Chemical Mixtures in United States Streams
- Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals Persist Downstream from the Source
- Chemicals Found in Treated Wastewater are Transported from Streams to Groundwater
- Pharmaceuticals and Other Chemicals Common in Landfill Waste
- Chemicals from Land-Applied Biosolids Persist in Soil
- Neuroactive Pharmaceuticals in Minnesota Rivers
- Complex Mixture of Contaminants Persists in Streams Miles from the Source
- Biological Activity of Steroid Hormones in U.S. Streams
- Improvements in Wastewater Treatment Reduces Endocrine Disruption in Fish
- Antibiotics in Groundwater Affect Natural Bacteria
- Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals in the Slick Scum that Covers Stones in Streams
- Manufacturing Facilities Release Pharmaceuticals to the Environment
- Hormones Degrade in the Environment!
- Measuring Antidepressants, Fungicides, and Insecticides in the Environment
- Emerging Contaminants Targeted in a Reconnaissance of Ground Water and Untreated Drinking-Water Sources
- Household Chemicals and Drugs Found in Biosolids from Wastewater Treatment Plants
- Are Pharmaceuticals in Your Watershed? Understanding the Fate of Pharmaceuticals and Other Contaminants in Watersheds
- Book Chapter on Exposure Modeling and Monitoring of Human Pharmaceuticals in the Environment
- USGS Scientists Contribute to New Book on Pharmaceuticals in the Environment
- USGS Scientists Develop New Method to Measure Pharmaceuticals in Water
- National Reconnaissance of Pharmaceuticals, Hormones and Other Organic Wastewater Contaminants in U.S. Streams is Making an Impact
- National Reconnaissance of Pharmaceuticals, Hormones, and Other Organic Wastewater Contaminants in Streams Named as One of the Top 100 Science Stories of the Year
- What's in Our Wastewaters and Where Does it Go?
-
Date published: September 11, 2018Status: ActiveWater and Wastewater Infrastructure Science Team
The team studies toxicants and pathogens in water resources from their sources, through watersheds, aquifers, and infrastructure to human and wildlife exposures. That information is used to develop decision tools that protect human and wildlife health.
Contacts: Paul M Bradley, Kelly Smalling -
Date published: September 11, 2018Status: ActiveImmunomodulation Science Team
The Immunomodulation Integrated Science Team focuses on contaminant and pathogen exposures in the environment that might influence the immune systems of wildlife, livestock, and companion animals. In collaboration with public-health officials, the Team also addresses potential human-health risks stemming from similar exposures. If actual risks are identified, this Team will inform...
Contacts: John Hansen, Ph.D., Natalie Karouna-Renier, Ph.D. -
Date published: October 25, 2016Status: CompletedGestodene Affects Fish Reproductive Behavior in Laboratory Exposure Study
Short-term laboratory exposure of adult fathead minnows to the human contraceptive progestin, gestodene (GES), at environmentally relevant concentrations induced rapid and negative effects on reproductive health and suggests that wild fish may be similarly affected.
Contacts: Michael T Meyer, Ph.D., Rachael F Lane, Ph.D. -
Date published: September 1, 2016Status: CompletedSwine Manure Application as a Source of Hepatitis E Virus and other Livestock-Related Pathogens
The presence of indicator bacteria, hepatitis E virus (HEV), and numerous bacterial pathogen genes increased following precipitation-induced runoff events in streams draining adjacent land surfaces in Iowa where swine manure was recently applied.
Contacts: Carrie Givens -
Date published: August 30, 2016Status: CompletedRecovery of Stream and Adjacent Groundwater After Wastewater Treatment Facility Closure
The hydrology and chemistry of a wastewater-impacted stream and adjacent groundwater responded rapidly (had fewer chemicals at lower concentrations) following wastewater treatment facility shutdown. However, the adjacent shallow groundwater remained a continuing source of some wastewater-derived contaminants to the stream at least 1 year post-shutdown.
-
Date published: June 16, 2016Status: CompletedSynthetic Progestin Affects Fish Reproductive Development and Behavior in Laboratory Exposure Study
Scientists conducted laboratory experiments on levonorgestrel (a synthetic progestin) and observed differential effects to males (reproductive behavior) and females (masculinization) of eastern mosquitofish (Gambusia holbrooki).
Contacts: Michael T Meyer, Ph.D. -
Date published: April 19, 2016Contaminants of Emerging Concern in the Environment
The USGS is conducting source-to-receptor research on a broad range of chemical and microbial contaminants including pharmaceuticals, personal care products, pathogens, antibiotic resistant genes, and natural toxins that are not commonly considered in environmental research but have the potential to impact environmental health.
-
Date published: November 13, 2015Status: Completed
Landfill Leachate Released to Wastewater Treatment Plants and other Environmental Pathways Contains a Mixture of Contaminants including Pharmaceuticals
New scientific research from the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) details how landfill leachate, disposed from landfills to environmental pathways, is host to numerous contaminants of emerging concern (CECs).
Contacts: Dana W Kolpin, Jason Masoner -
Date published: August 26, 2015Status: CompletedPotential Exposure to Bacteria and Viruses Weeks after Swine Manure Spill
Manure spills may be an underappreciated pathway for livestock-derived contaminants to enter streams. Scientists from the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) and Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health studied an Iowa stream after the release of a large volume of swine manure (a manure spill). The scientists observed an increase in viruses...
Contacts: Michael Focazio, PhD, Carrie Givens -
Date published: July 6, 2015Status: CompletedLong-Term Study Finds Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals in Urban Waterways
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) scientists determined that endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) were present in wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluent, water, and fish tissue in urban waterways in the Great Lakes and upper Mississippi River Regions (Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, and Ohio) during 1999 through 2009.
Contacts: Larry B Barber, II
Complex mixtures, complex responses: Assessing pharmaceutical mixtures using field and laboratory approaches
Pharmaceuticals are present in low concentrations (<100 ng/L) in most municipal wastewater effluents but may be elevated locally because of factors such as input from pharmaceutical formulation facilities. Using existing concentration data, the authors assessed pharmaceuticals in laboratory exposures of fathead minnows (Pimephales...
Schoenfuss, Heiko L.; Furlong, Edward T.; Phillips, Patrick J.; Scott, Tia-Marie; Kolpin, Dana W.; Cetkovic-Cvrlje, Marina; Lesteberg, Kelsey E.; Rearick, Daniel C.-
Date published: November 13, 2015Understanding how Pharmaceuticals in the Environment Affect Fish
Fish health may be affected by pharmaceuticals in treated wastewater released into streams and other water bodies, according to a recent laboratory and field study by the Aquatic Toxicology Laboratory at St. Cloud State University and the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS).